Bennett's Store - KENNEBUNK

Although some people may think I'm crazy for saying this, I was not impressed with the sandwiches at this restaurant. I had heard great things about their steak... read more Although some people may think I'm crazy for saying this, I was not impressed with the sandwiches at this restaurant. I had heard great things about their steak and cheese sandwich, which is a favorite of mine that I have tried at many places. Unfortunately, the main issue was that the rolls on both of the $13 subs were not fully toasted. They felt soggy, steamed, and lackluster. I had to toast them in the oven to make them more palatable. The steak and vegetables inside were tasty, but the overall experience was hindered by the roll issue. Despite this, I still gave them a generous 4-star rating and will give them another try as it may have just been an isolated problem. The service was good and quick, and the staff seemed very organized with a clean kitchen.

Love the new Mediterranean option! I got it in a bowl and it was fabulous. Plan it for online and super efficient, simple and punctual! read more Love the new Mediterranean option! I got it in a bowl and it was fabulous. Plan it for online and super efficient, simple and punctual!

Great sandwich, but they don't melt the cheese on the tuna melt for some reason. Large sandwich with fresh ingredients. The bread was roasted... also. this is s... read more Great sandwich, but they don't melt the cheese on the tuna melt for some reason. Large sandwich with fresh ingredients. The bread was roasted... also. this is so convenient when you go to the beach. You can eat with a beautiful view of the sea.

During my honeymoon in Kennebunk, I decided to stop by this restaurant on a whim and now I'm at a loss for what to do. It's been a month and I can't stop thinki... read more During my honeymoon in Kennebunk, I decided to stop by this restaurant on a whim and now I'm at a loss for what to do. It's been a month and I can't stop thinking about the tuna sandwich I had there. It was just perfect. The bread was soft and delicious, the tuna portion was generous, and the tomato and lettuce were crisp and fresh. There was nothing extraordinary about the sandwich itself, but when all the elements came together, it was simply the best sandwich I've ever had. Now that I'm back in Brooklyn, I've tried to recreate the experience at different delis and bagel shops, but none of them compare. The tuna sandwich at Bennett's holds a special place in my memory that I can't seem to replicate. I'm torn between being upset that I can't find a comparable sandwich elsewhere, or grateful for the wonderful experience I had at Bennett's. Dine here at your own risk.

I used to get subs here regularly when I lived up there (96-98) and it was a small family affair. They were the best sandwiches around. My go to was the chicken... read more I used to get subs here regularly when I lived up there (96-98) and it was a small family affair. They were the best sandwiches around. My go to was the chicken cheese steak. Now I'm back down the coast and I find myself thinking about Bennett's from time to time. Wishing they weren't 10 hours away. It's good to see that they're still going strong. Great place then, and from what I read, great place now. Can't wait until I can get back up there again and get another sandwich or two or three.