Cafe Mexicali - Johnstown

#6 - Mexican - Johnstown, Salad, Soup
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Cafe Mexicali

Cafe Mexicali
4.3 / 5 (164 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Cafe Mexicali from Johnstown featuring all 8 menus and drinks can be found here on the list.

Cafe Mexicali offers a tantalizing menu that includes flavorful burritos and fresh, house-made tortillas, attracting patrons with its delicious food. Many diners rave about the tender and juicy fillings, complemented by prompt service. However, safety concerns overshadow the dining experience, as mask compliance among staff and customers is lacking. While the food is praised, confusion surrounding the menu and high prices for family meals raises questions about overall value. For those seeking a safe and fulfilling dining experience, it may be more prudent to consider alternatives or visit another location.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lonie

Images

Cafe Mexicali Food Cafe Mexicali Food Cafe Mexicali Food Cafe Mexicali Food Cafe Mexicali Food Cafe Mexicali Food Cafe Mexicali Food

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 164 reviews

Was Lonie Brekke at Cafe Mexicali a mag?
4 we had caffe mexacali with the black. it was very good. I had it in a bowl because of incompatibility. the others had it in flourtortilla. at least 1 he had in the bowl because it was so hard to get.

What Danika Fadel dislikes about Cafe Mexicali:
Simply don't feel safe eating here. Very few of the guests in line are encouraged or expected to wear masks, and not a SINGLE employee was properly wearing a mask either. Ordering online has 100% of the time resulted in wrong orders, so the only way to ensure the food is right is to go in person, but with the lack of safety at this restaurant I just can't bring myself to eat there. It's a shame because the food is gr... View all feedback.

fenne27-1
19.05.2022

The food was delicious and the staff were generally helpful and friendly. However, we found the menu to be confusing during our first visit. The restaurant was clean with a terrace dining area available, but the atmosphere was just okay. The food was served in large aluminum pans, which made it difficult to eat the crushed burrito. For the amount of money spent on a family of four, we could have eaten at a nicer restaurant for a similar price. Overall, Cafe Mexicali was not a good value for the money spent.

eleanore57
19.05.2022

The meal was fantastic. I ordered a shredded chicken burrito, and the meat was tender, juicy, and flavorful. I usually like my burritos to have a little more filling, but overall it was a great experience. No complaints about the service, as we received our orders promptly.

lillie-hintz
19.05.2022

I had a fantastic experience at this restaurant today! My order was quite large, but the entire staff was more than happy to accommodate all of my requests without any complaints, despite the short notice. The group of 10 people I was with thoroughly enjoyed everything we ordered, trying almost every item on the menu. Thank you so much for the delicious food and impeccable service!

lonie26
19.05.2022

4 we had caffe mexacali with the black. it was very good. I had it in a bowl because of incompatibility. the others had it in flourtortilla. at least 1 he had in the bowl because it was so hard to get

eleanore57
19.05.2022

My green chile pork breakfast burrito didn't last long enough for me to take a photo and I'm not sorry.They make fresh tortillas in house. Everyone there was smiling and happy to be there too.Run, don't walk. You won't be disappointed!

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.