Reviews - Pace's Pizzeria
Reviews summary
Nestled in a charming small town, this pizza restaurant has garnered mixed reviews from diners. While many appreciate the delicious pies, showcasing quality ingredients and well-balanced flavors, some have faced disappointments with order accuracy and service. The inviting atmosphere, especially the outdoor patio, enhances the experience, yet inconsistency in wait times and staff attentiveness can detract from it. Despite occasional hiccups, the overall sentiment leans positive, highlighting its kid-friendly environment and homemade quality as key attractions. Diners often recommend ordering ahead to ensure a satisfying meal at this bustling local favorite.
Was Jamie Smith at Pace's Pizzeria a mag?
Delicious Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: blt Pizza, Meatball Sandwich, Pizza Sandwich with Pepperoni, Pepsi Products, Paces Special Pizza, White Pizza, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Green Olives, Black Olives, Chicken Wing Pizza, Meatball Float, Sausage Float, Gluten Free Crust with Mushrooms and Fresh Mozzarella View all feedback.
What Mike and Beth Burton dislikes about Pace's Pizzeria:
Out of towners. Was recommended by a nearby ice cream shop to get pizza here. Disappointed. The pizza had a bit too much grease and was a bit on the thinner side. While it was edible and filling, it wouldn't be on the top of the list to return to... For my preferences anyway. Atmosphere looked inviting (we got ours to go). Was standing at register waiting to pick up for a few minutes before being acknowledged. Associ... View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 05.03.2025
The best in everything! And the employees showed great help) I express my gratitude! And very tasty pizza! I have never eaten this anywhere in all the states!!! Service: Takeaway Meal type: Other Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
The pizza was good- just smaller than expected and cut oddly. I just wish they also offered wings! We visited when staying for the weekend (I love Lucy Museum. Would def eat there again if we happened to be passing through. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $1–10
Among all the places in the area that sell pizza with premade dough and too much undercooked cheese, this place gets it right. The pizza was built with the correct proportions and done-ness. I just had a medium plain pizza. Plus when you walk in the door it actually smells like a pizza place! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Called in a phone order for pick up. Very pleasant on the phone, order was done on time and (of course) the salad, meatballs and pizza was delicious! Thank you for a great dinner! Service: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
I love their pizza! Haven’t tried anything else but this is my favorite place in Jamestown to order pizza from. I ordered a large pie with pepperoni, pineapple and jalapeños. Service: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Last update : 28.09.2024
Prices are outrageous and not a lot of options
The ?
The pizza was tasty, but it was smaller than I anticipated and the slices were cut in a strange way. I also wish they had wings on the menu! We went there during a weekend trip while visiting the Lucy Museum. I would definitely eat there again if we happen to be in the area.
Pizza is delish!! Staff is very nice. Order ahead, usually 20-25 minutes. Worth the wait!!??
Homemade great quality.Friendly staff.Small town family place.Very busy place.Food is tasty. Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizza available. Parking: Parking can be a challenge depending on when you are there.Worth the walk if you have to park a bit away.
Last update : 17.02.2024
First time using door dash to order our favorite pizza from paces. The salads were crisp and the 17"paces special was hot. We usually eat in but will do this again.
Ordered a white pizza and a traditional pizza with pepperoni. Both were excellent! Best pizza there is!
Garlic Bread with Cheese has quickly risen to the top of my favorites list, and the Meatball Appetizer is also quite delicious. However, the 9-inch White Pizza should have its ingredients clearly listed, as I was surprised to find sliced tomatoes as a topping, which were not mentioned anywhere but were visible in the picture. Despite this oversight, the pizza is still very enjoyable.
Paces Pizza doesn't taste the way it used to. While it's still decent, something has definitely changed.
I really missed the garlic on the pizza; if it was there, I couldn't taste it. Overall, the pizza was lacking in flavor, and I was quite disappointed.
