Lenny's Pizza Bistro (aka Lenny's Of Jamesport) - Feedback

If you're in search of a fantastic slice of Sicilian pizza (or an entire pie), this is undeniably the top spot to go on the North Fork of Long Island. Food: 5 S... read more If you're in search of a fantastic slice of Sicilian pizza (or an entire pie), this is undeniably the top spot to go on the North Fork of Long Island. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Lenny's pizza is the best, but don't get the fried calamari or baked clams. They are restaurant depot at best. Very disappointed, considering the product and th... read more Lenny's pizza is the best, but don't get the fried calamari or baked clams. They are restaurant depot at best. Very disappointed, considering the product and the price Service: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 1 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 4

Manager yesterday was incompetent in regards to customer service. Ordered the firewood wild mushroom pizza and received a regular oven baked mushroom pizza. I d... read more Manager yesterday was incompetent in regards to customer service. Ordered the firewood wild mushroom pizza and received a regular oven baked mushroom pizza. I didn't make a big deal out of it because our server was new to the job, but when the check came in I asked him to adjust the price since we didn't get what we paid for. The manager said no adjustment and didn't even do it in person. Clearly he wasn't interested in us returning to his establishment. He earned that. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $50–100 Food: 1 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2

The Rigatoni Bolognese is great !! Big portion. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 read more The Rigatoni Bolognese is great !! Big portion. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Lenny's is a must-visit every time we return to the North Fork to visit! Whether you are here for the pizza or an Italian meal that may as well be home-cooked,... read more Lenny's is a must-visit every time we return to the North Fork to visit! Whether you are here for the pizza or an Italian meal that may as well be home-cooked, you won't be disappointed! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Slice of Pizza

The food here is quite good, and the portion sizes are generous. However, the restaurant could really benefit from some renovations, as it feels a bit outdated.... read more The food here is quite good, and the portion sizes are generous. However, the restaurant could really benefit from some renovations, as it feels a bit outdated. They do have a nice bar, but our waitress, an older woman, didn't offer any modern cocktail options. We opted for some wine instead, which was very nice. I think they should consider bringing in younger staff for the bar. That said, the food itself is really enjoyable.

The pizza at this place is amazing, and the staff is super friendly. I had the chicken parm pizza, which was loaded with chicken and cheese. It's a great pizza... read more The pizza at this place is amazing, and the staff is super friendly. I had the chicken parm pizza, which was loaded with chicken and cheese. It's a great pizza spot that isn't widely known to vineyard visitors, so it's usually not very busy.

Totally mistreated my wife while she was there with her nieces and nephews and others, then tried lying to me by saying they were busy when pictures from my wif... read more Totally mistreated my wife while she was there with her nieces and nephews and others, then tried lying to me by saying they were busy when pictures from my wife?s phone was the complete opposite. I can only speculate why ?certain? people are treated acertain way in certain places, but that?s up for debate. Thankfully I wasn?t there, as I am not as nice and my money is just asgood and probably better than anyone else who patrons there, especially from Suffolk County. Never go there again.

Tonight we came across a really fine Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Ronnie our waitress was so amazing and helpful. She took great care of us and her service... read more Tonight we came across a really fine Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Ronnie our waitress was so amazing and helpful. She took great care of us and her service was great. Tonight I had the veal cardinale was amazing. It is a break cutlet in amarsala reduction, mozzarella, prosciutto and shallots. It was so delicious and a very generous portion, served with a side ofpasta. Delicious! My wife had the chicken francaise which she enjoyed as well. Both orders were generous and served with theirfresh Italian bread. I highly recommend Lenny's. Their food is amazing, delicious and nice size!

Tonight, we discovered a wonderful Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Our waitress, Ronnie, was fantastic and incredibly attentive. She took excellent care of us,... read more Tonight, we discovered a wonderful Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Our waitress, Ronnie, was fantastic and incredibly attentive. She took excellent care of us, and her service was top-notch. I ordered the veal cardinale, which was simply outstanding. It featured a breaded cutlet in a marsala reduction, topped with mozzarella, prosciutto, and shallots. Every bite was delicious, and the portion was quite generous, accompanied by a side of pasta. My wife chose the chicken francaise, which she also enjoyed. Both dishes were hearty and came with fresh Italian bread. I highly recommend Lenny's. Their food is amazing, flavorful, and very satisfying!

I had an amazing Veal Cardinale at this restaurant. The bread served with dinner was fantastic. It's a wonderful place to dine! Parking is convenient and secure... read more I had an amazing Veal Cardinale at this restaurant. The bread served with dinner was fantastic. It's a wonderful place to dine! Parking is convenient and secure, and there is easy access for those in wheelchairs.

The chicken Parm pizza slices are so cheesy and delicious! read more The chicken Parm pizza slices are so cheesy and delicious!

Look for pizza. Nothing spectacular, but it's quick, simple economical. Not bad its read more Look for pizza. Nothing spectacular, but it's quick, simple economical. Not bad its

Went to Lenny's with my Dad and ordered the chicken parm and he got a chicken and pasta meal. The portions were large and tasty. Service was good and the atmosp... read more Went to Lenny's with my Dad and ordered the chicken parm and he got a chicken and pasta meal. The portions were large and tasty. Service was good and the atmosphere was great. Prices were within reasion. I would recommend this place.

Nice take out pizza ? with little sit down restaurant on the side. Nice food, and service. read more Nice take out pizza ? with little sit down restaurant on the side. Nice food, and service.

Tonight, we stumbled upon a fantastic Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Our server, Ronnie, was exceptional and extremely attentive, providing excellent service... read more Tonight, we stumbled upon a fantastic Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Our server, Ronnie, was exceptional and extremely attentive, providing excellent service throughout our visit. I ordered the veal Marsala, which was expertly prepared with a rich Marsala reduction, mozzarella, prosciutto, and tortellini. It was absolutely delicious, served in a generous portion alongside a side of pasta. My wife chose the chicken fra diavolo, and she thoroughly enjoyed it as well. Both dishes were plentiful and came with fresh Italian bread. I highly recommend Lenny’s; the food is amazing, flavorful, and served in generous portions!

I initially intended to sit at the bar at Lenny's for a few drinks, but since the dining room was closed on Tuesday, I decided to eat in the restaurant instead.... read more I initially intended to sit at the bar at Lenny's for a few drinks, but since the dining room was closed on Tuesday, I decided to eat in the restaurant instead. I'm really glad I made that choice. The Baked Ziti was amazing, and I also loved the house salad as an appetizer. Debbie was an absolute treasure—she was a wonderful and friendly host. I would definitely come back in a heartbeat!

Lenny's is simply the best! I live on Shelter Island, and there's no other pizza place or bistro on the East End that even comes close. The quality, flavor, and... read more Lenny's is simply the best! I live on Shelter Island, and there's no other pizza place or bistro on the East End that even comes close. The quality, flavor, and variety of their menu items are outstanding. It's absolutely worth taking the ferry and enjoying a beautiful autumn drive on the North Fork, or any time of year for that matter. The staff is friendly, and the pizza is absolutely amazing!

The staff at Lenny's Pizza Bistro is very friendly. The thin, crispy pizza is delightful, featuring a flavorful sauce and tasty homemade meatballs. Although the... read more The staff at Lenny's Pizza Bistro is very friendly. The thin, crispy pizza is delightful, featuring a flavorful sauce and tasty homemade meatballs. Although the bar and dining room were closed during my visit (they open at 4 PM), I took a quick look inside and it appeared to be really nice. I'm not a local, but I work at the Valero gas station nearby, and many customers have recommended this restaurant as a great place to eat.

The pizza by the slice is excellent, along with the rice balls and sandwiches. The homemade tomato sauce is incredibly delicious. What stands out the most is th... read more The pizza by the slice is excellent, along with the rice balls and sandwiches. The homemade tomato sauce is incredibly delicious. What stands out the most is the exceptional service. The woman behind the counter was friendly, helpful, and patient. We'll definitely return when we're in the area again!

I absolutely love this restaurant! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, setting it apart from other nearby spots. I highly recommend giving it a visit! read more I absolutely love this restaurant! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, setting it apart from other nearby spots. I highly recommend giving it a visit!

When we returned to our place and opened the box of pizza, the aroma was fantastic. The pizza was generously sized and loaded with mushrooms and caramelized oni... read more When we returned to our place and opened the box of pizza, the aroma was fantastic. The pizza was generously sized and loaded with mushrooms and caramelized onions—definitely not skimpy with the toppings. It was delicious and among the best pizzas I've ever had. The ice cream was delightful as well. Overall, we were very happy with our meal. If you’re considering this place, don’t hesitate; you won’t be disappointed!

I recently needed assistance in choosing food for a gathering of about 20 people, and Lenny provided the best suggestions that made the event a success. Wheneve... read more I recently needed assistance in choosing food for a gathering of about 20 people, and Lenny provided the best suggestions that made the event a success. Whenever my grandchildren and I are in the area, we make it a priority to have dinner and pizza from Lenny’s—it’s as important to us as a doctor's appointment. Lenny always serves the most delicious pizza, and we have never been disappointed.