Reelcatch - ISLAMORADA

Outstanding service, very friendly employees, not a single mistake on the orders, prompt attention to every need or request, we are a small local motorcycle group, and have been to just about to all the restaurants in the Keys. And this is byfar one of the best, good food, great atmosphere, top of the line service, I highly recommend it.

This is a hotel restaurant at Amara Cay Resort. This dog friendly property looks beautiful. The hotel restaurant is ReelCatch. The decor was very nice. This Friday night, they had a one man band playing. The restaurant is open and in the lobby. I'd call it beach elegant. I tried an app and dessert: Chicken BItes and 12 Layer Chocolate Cake. Both were a solid 4*. The chicken was tender. They had several sauces, I tried the Thai and Buffalo. They also had a honey BBQ and maybe 1-2 others. They were nice enough to split the order and did so in separate bowls. Very good! The cake was rich and moist. I enjoyed the fresh strawberry topping along with whipped cream. So good. Really fun experience, especially with the live music. Give them a try.

Service is extremely slow. Our party ate breakfast and an afternoon dessert. Two encounters, both with slower than slow service, neither with many guests present. The food was good and overpriced as expected.

Super amazing hotel bar and restaurant! Burgers were good, service was awesome and the beach was superb!

Horrible breakfast. Menu is not accurate with pricing or items. Service was slow. The unsolicited baby advice was almost as bad as the sausage.