Stoltzfus Meats - Feedback

American, North American, Delivery Services

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.3 out of 5
Impressive | 1617 reviews

Outside Images

Stoltzfus Meats Outside

Reviews from various websites

Restaurantji

Last update : 30.08.2023

4.6 ★ from 263 reviews
eddie-677
Eddie 30.08.2023 - 06:17

A large meat market selling meat from the Stoltzfus factory. Also has a bakery

chris-660
Chris 30.08.2023 - 06:17

Bring a cooler or buy one of theirs! The cheese and meat selection is fantastic! Fresh bread and bakery goods and so much more. This is a Must stop!

lori-660
Lori 30.08.2023 - 06:17

We always make it a point to stop by here at least once during our visit to the area. The meats are top-notch, along with many other favorites! You definitely shouldn't miss this place!

howard-348
Howard 30.08.2023 - 06:17

It takes a really long time to receive your food order. I recommend visiting their website and placing your order ahead of time. By the time you've done that, you'll be ready to enjoy your delicious lunch. And yes, this is definitely the place to buy meat and cheese!

mrsroamino
MrsRoaminO 30.08.2023 - 06:17

Fantastic market and deli! We enjoyed lunch under the gazebo, and the sandwiches were enormous with delicious fresh bread. We also grabbed some peanut butter cookies and a berry bread loaf to take home. We highly recommend Stoltzfus Meats!

A beloved Lancaster County meat market and sandwich shop blends a classic butcher, bakery and deli into a must-stop for meat lovers and families. The roster—jerky, smoked sausages, fresh cuts, cheeses, baked goods and standout sandwiches (notably pulled pork)—delivers high-quality flavors and convenient takeaways. Friendly service and reasonable prices are common, though experiences vary: some diners report cold food, missing ingredients, occasional blandness, rude staff, and surprisingly high single-item prices. Overall a strong destination for hearty fare, but expect occasional inconsistency.

Int Restaurants

Last update : 17.07.2023

4.9 ★ from 1212 reviews
lisa-333
Lisa 17.07.2023 - 08:44

Bought 3 meat products on our last trip to Intercourse hoping they would make their way home to Pittsburgh. Have eaten 2 of the 3 so far and they were so good. Chicken breast marinated in bourbon sauce and chicken burgers with cheese bacon, ranch. Both were so good. Still have actual hamburger patties to make but I'm sure they will be just as good. Next time I make the 4 hour drive out there will definately be another stop for more.

carol-147
Carol 17.07.2023 - 08:44

This is a fantastic spot to stop and grab a bite to eat—just step inside and enjoy the delightful scent of freshly baked goods! I was driving slowly this morning because snow plows were still clearing the roads in that area. I decided to stop for breakfast, and the toast with apple butter was absolutely delicious. I learned that the bread comes from their bakery located at the back of the store, so I followed my nose and ended up purchasing a loaf of their white bread. I made sure to keep that loaf safe all the way home; I had a flight out of Philadelphia in the evening with a layover in Phoenix. I savored some toast before heading to bed here in California.

tanya-64
Tanya 17.07.2023 - 08:44

Absolutely the best food in town! This place is a must-visit! I make the drive from New Jersey to Lancaster and always stop here for breakfast, then I take dinner home for my family. My kids are always asking for the pulled pork and mac and cheese!

william-207
William 17.07.2023 - 08:44

This review focuses on Amos' Place, the charming little restaurant located within the Deli. I ordered the sausage sandwich, while my wife enjoyed the chicken salad sandwich, and we shared a side of fries. The sausage was served piping hot, fresh off the grill, and was topped with sautéed peppers, onions, and a delicious sauce. The flavor of the sausage sandwich was fantastic and brought back memories of the sausage I used to have at Stoltzfus Farm Restaurant, which closed several years ago. The bread was incredibly soft and fresh! I highly recommend this spot for families visiting the Kitchen Kettle Village across the street!

ann-105
Ann 17.07.2023 - 08:44

My husband just love the grillers. There is a wide variety of favors and we like them all. Their pork chops are wonderful. We always leave the store with a different types of cheeses. Stoltzfus is the best place to go to get quality meats and cheeses.

Google

Last update : 10.11.2023

3.4 ★ from 9 reviews
john-galloway-cactus
John 10.11.2023 - 12:23

I ordered the Reuben and was initially unsure, but it turned out to be the best I’ve ever had! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

oliver-dalbow
Oliver 10.11.2023 - 12:23

I don't see how this restaurant has received 4 and 5-star reviews; the food is only average at best. The sausage sandwich was quite bland—without the sauce and peppers, it would have had no flavor at all. The chicken breast was small and also lacking in taste, and the French fries were soggy. For lunch, I would rate the experience poorly. The price for each person was around $20-30.

sharon-jackson-johns
Sharon 10.11.2023 - 12:23

**Service:** Takeout **Meal Type:** Other **Price per Person:** $20–30 **Food:** 4/5 **Service:** 4/5 **Atmosphere:** 3/5

ernest-cidoni-1
Ernest 10.11.2023 - 12:23

- **Service:** Dine-in - **Meal Type:** Breakfast - **Price Per Person:** $1–10 - **Food:** 5/5 - **Service:** 5/5 - **Atmosphere:** 5/5 - **Parking:** Abundant parking available - **Parking Options:** Free parking lot Highly recommended!

john-boggs
John 10.11.2023 - 12:23

The food was cold—every single dish. My wife ordered home fries with cheese and peppers but received neither. When she inquired about the missing items, the staff responded with rolled eyes and an obvious lack of politeness, even letting out an audible sigh. They eventually returned with the cheese, but still no peppers. I was told the peppers were included, but there was only one visible in the dish (see attached photo). We've always made it a point to visit Amos during our trips to Lancaster due to their food and service, but something has clearly gone wrong. This was likely our last visit, which is quite unusual for Amos.

Menu

Last update : 02.05.2023

4.4 ★ from 8 reviews

Massive selection of high quality meats: jerky, smoked sausages, cutlets, sirloin and various other steaks, burgers, bacon all with various spices and cheese options. The store also has various cheeses, chips, sweets, baked goods and more. The prices are pretty reasonable considering the quality. Great location and friendly service.

It's conveniently located across from a nice Amish furniture place where we were shopping. It has a counter service restaurant with great hot and sandwiches. Price is reasonable with decent serving portions and quality meat. The adjacent market store also has a large selection of other food items in addition to various type of meat products.

Stoltzfus Meats is a spacious market offering a variety of freshly prepared foods, a butcher shop with an extensive selection of meats and cheeses, a bakery, and a range of spices. The quality of the meats is outstanding, with many different options available. Before shopping, we enjoyed lunch outside in the pleasant weather. We tried the Amos super melt, turkey sub, and Italian sub from their menu, each accompanied by a bag of chips. All the sandwiches were delicious, especially thanks to the high-quality meats used. Prices are reasonable, particularly for the meat products. It’s clear that at Stoltzfus Meats, you get what you pay for: fresh packages of meat and other quality goods.

I’ve been a loyal customer of Stoltzfus Meats for years, and it never disappoints. I always make sure to stop here for lunch before heading home. This time, I tried the ultimate pulled pork sandwich, and I wish I had done so sooner. It was hands down the best sandwich I’ve ever tasted! Packed with pulled pork, Cheddar cheese, and coleslaw, it keeps me craving more. The Italian hoagie is also a reliable and delicious choice. This place is outstanding, and they truly know their craft!

A well-known spot for tourists, but I was disappointed to find that the croissants served at the restaurant were actually store-bought from Costco. This made me doubt the authenticity of the food.

Sirved

Last update : 31.03.2025

4.6 ★ from 112 reviews

Stoltzfus meats and a large market that has fresh made food, butcher with meats, cheeses, a baked goods section and variety of seasonings. All of the meats look great and there is a variety of different types. Before shopping around we had lunch and wereable to sit outside and enjoy the nice weather. Our grub of choice were the Amos super melt, turkey sub and Italian sub all witha bag of chips. All of which were good, especially with having the quality meats. Prices are reasonable, especially whenshopping for meats. Remember you get what you pay for, fresh packages meats and goods.

A place of tourist attraction. Croissants in the package of Costco were directly served in the meal there. Not sure how authentic the food would be.

I have been coming here for years and it never disappoints. I always make sure to stop here for lunch before I head back home. This time I tried their ultimate pulled pork sandwich and I regret never trying this before. It was the best sandwich I haveever tasted. The bun was packed with pulled pork, cheddar cheese, and coleslaw. It is making me hungry all over again makingthis review. You can never go wrong and play it safe with their Italian hoagie too. Great place and they know what they aredoing

Such an awesome meat market. They have everything from fresh to packaged meats. The selection is phenomenal. You can also get their meats packaged and frozen. They have a large deli counter to get sliced meats and salads. A butcher counter to get fresh meats. They have a large selection of meat sticks and different kinds of grilling sausages. You will also find fresh bakedpies, cookies, cakes and breads There is a nice selection of bulk dried items as well as a great selection of canned items. Ifyou are hungry there is also a sandwich counter where you can get a variety of sandwiches, soups and other tasty treats. Thestore is very clean and the staff is friendly and helpful.

Amazing food and the portions looked bigger than in any other breakfast place I've ever had. We enjoyed it so much that we even decided to come for lunch and were not disappointed either. Delicious sandwiches and chicken. I wish they were open Sundays so Ican have one more meal there before leaving. We will be back again for sure!

Facebookpag

Last update : 04.03.2025

5.0 ★ from 1 reviews
debby-moran
Debby 04.03.2025 - 03:50

The food was fantastic, and the service was incredibly welcoming. I would absolutely love to go back!

Restaurantguru
2.7 ★ from 12 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Intercourse