Johnny Tomatoes - Indian Trail

I am from long island and as any islander knows, not all ny pizza is remotely the same. You find your spot and stay loyal to it. To me this is the best pizza in indian trail hands down!! Perfect crust and flavor (always judge the quality with a cheese pie). We'll be back to explore the menu. Great job

My husband and I were super skeptical. We are new here and so far the food in this town is just not good. We decided to try again hoping for the best. We looked at reviews, photos and decided to go for it. We ordered the margarita pizza and a side of fries. Both of our faces lit up as we took the first bite of pizza. The sauce was flavorful and the pizza was not a soggy sloppy mess. The crust was perfect. Finally. Something that reminded me of my old stomping ground. Our taste buds have been saved. We found a spot where we won't have any hesitations in ordering again. Will also tell other people about this place.

I ordered takeout today- a spaghetti with tomato sauce and since I have a dairy allergy I asked for no cheese, but when I opened it I realized it had cheese on it.. I called them and let them know. They made me new spaghetti and were so apologetic about the mistake. I really appreciate it when restaurants take responsibility and fix things. Thanks so much you guys for awesome service. The spaghetti was great as well! Also if you want a pizza with no cheese they make those too :

Born and raised on Long island .Just moved here and I was depressed as there is no good pizza here.I passed this place last night and ordered a fresh cheese pie .I felt like I was home .This pizza is amazing ,the gravy is delicious. I cant wait to come back you have no idea how happy my family and I are knowing there is real Italian food here.

You owe my mom an apology. I had to slap her, your pizza was so good. Also, I need you to pick up the bill for the hole in the wall from when I took a bite into your canoli’s! Doesn’t get much better