Scarlet Oak Tavern - HINGHAM

Arrived for 7:30 reservations and was told they were running behind and would be 10-15 minutes wait, turned into a 45 minute wait which everyone with reservatio... read more Arrived for 7:30 reservations and was told they were running behind and would be 10-15 minutes wait, turned into a 45 minute wait which everyone with reservations said they were waiting, hostess did not handle this situation very well as they kept telling everyone the same wait time which was not true at all. Waitress was very good and food was very good but the beginning of the evening really soured the night

I chose to go here for my 50th birthday and it was such a great choice! Beautiful atmosphere, great food and great company. The waitress was so nice and profess... read more I chose to go here for my 50th birthday and it was such a great choice! Beautiful atmosphere, great food and great company. The waitress was so nice and professional and attentive. I will definitely be coming back. I loved the fireplace when I first walked in to the right and I thought that would be a great place to meet a friend for a cocktail.

The Filet Mignon is unbelievable. The Red wine reduction sauce is to die for. Always friendly staff , nice romantic setting. read more The Filet Mignon is unbelievable. The Red wine reduction sauce is to die for. Always friendly staff , nice romantic setting.

I 've been having Thanksgiving dinner here with the family, except for last year, for the past five years, or so. It has always been an enjoyable experience, wi... read more I 've been having Thanksgiving dinner here with the family, except for last year, for the past five years, or so. It has always been an enjoyable experience, with good food and excellent service. This is no longer the case, even though the menu is priced40% higher than previous occasions. The food is the same, but attention to detail , such as New York Strip medium rare, orTurkey Dinner dark meat only, fall on deaf ears. Service is rushed, incomplete and impersonal. The noticeable decline inperformance, may be a sign of the times , but I won 't be driving 3.5 4 hours, on Thanksgiving day, to eat here, ever again.

Excellent for small to mid-size functions. Get your own room even if it's for like 7-10 people. Really nice staff. Food was excellent. Plenty of bar seating and... read more Excellent for small to mid-size functions. Get your own room even if it's for like 7-10 people. Really nice staff. Food was excellent. Plenty of bar seating and you can be as casual or as fancy as you'd like with this place, which makes it a greatplace for everybody.