Pizza One - Haskell

#1 - Pizza - Haskell, #15 - Fast Food - Haskell, Sandwiches
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +19738351600

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Pizza One in Haskell. At the moment, there are 47 menus and drinks on the list.

Pizza One, located in Haskell, NJ, is a beloved Italian restaurant that has garnered an impressive average rating of 4.1 stars. Open this week from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM, it’s wise to call ahead at (973) 835-1600 to ensure you secure a table. With a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, including delicious vegetarian options, there truly is something for everyone at Pizza One. If you’re curious about similar dining experiences, be sure to check out Kitchen and Beer Bar or Brooklyn Pizza Kitchen. Have you dined with us before? We invite you to leave a review and share your thoughts!.

Last update: 28.12.2025 from: Danielle

Images

Pizza One Food Pizza One Food Pizza One Food Pizza One Food Pizza One Food Pizza One Food Pizza One Drink Pizza One Food

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1254 reviews

Was Anonym at Pizza One a mag?
Order here always as a working health professional they are especially for me the sandwiches hot and cold as well as the pizzas are all freshly made good and definitely worth every penny thanks to pizza a View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Pizza One:
Their pizza isn't what it use to be, lots of sloppy deliveries with half your sauce from pasta dishes gone. Some dishes you can tell something has changed or using different cheaper ingredients. Whats usually good and you can't really mess up on are their signature sandwiches, but that depends on if they're using good bread for a sandwich. They're not the only ones in town now and have great competition, BROOKLYN PIZ... View all feedback.

rocco-minervini
Rocco 01.10.2024 - 08:05

Parking: amazing food. great pizza and chicken parm off the hook. greek shad ??

michelle-miner-2
Michelle 01.10.2024 - 08:05

Amazing pizza place consistently quality food Dietary restrictions: Pretty good gluten free crust

giovanna-christ
giovanna 01.10.2024 - 08:05

Just received a supreme pie and the pizza is too thin falling apart very disappointing someone there keeps making the pizza too thin! It happens often

danielle-castro-frag
Danielle 09.04.2025 - 21:24

We order delivery from here at least once or twice a week! Their catering is also phenomenal! I have hosted several parties over the years and everyone raves about the food. So much so, that whenever we go to catered events of other family not in the area, the hosts ask us to pick up food from Pizza One. And when I?m feeling up to it? their cauliflower pizza is REALLY good!

gabe-sasso
Gabe 09.04.2025 - 21:24

Grabbed takeout at The Haskell Pizza One location Sunday on an impromptu basis. We were planning to get food from a nearby competitor that advertised closing at 10PM. A 9:05 PM call we made to place our order revealed, we 're closed, yeah we need toupdate our google. Yes you do!! Please become one with your Google. We 'd describe our order from Pizza One as Medium Plus innature across the board. The size large Italian Sub which was advertised as being 14 in size had to be at the very least 16 .It was easily 2 meals for someone with a Medium Plus appetite. It was quite tasty and was on point to satisfy the Italian Subcraving I 'd been carrying around for several hours. Similar can be said for the small Chicken Vodka Parm. Claiming to be 7 insize it weighed in at Medium Plus and a likely 8 or 9 inches. No rulers were used to estimate length, but as sandwich veteranswe know our way around a hero. The bread utilized for each sandwich was better than what is typical for the bread thatsandwiches are made on at most pizza places. That said it 's not destination bread, but it 's worth noting that in surpassingaverage expectations in it 's category it also achieves Medium Plus status. The third item we ordered was a Rice Ball and itwas medium in size and tastiness. Certainly passable, but not of particular note, thus it does not reach Medium Plus status.We didn 't sample the pizza but it looked tasty in the display case. Both the standard round pies and the square pie in the casehad pretty thick looking crusts. Overall Rating: Medium Plus.

  • Sandwiches

    Clokin Chicken
    Clokin Chicken
    $11.2
    Hot Italian Hero
    Hot Italian Hero
    $6.6
  • Steak & Gyro

    Ny Yankees
    Ny Yankees
    $7.0
    Ny Mets
    Ny Mets
    $11.7
  • Special Maki Roll

    Brooklyn Nets
    Brooklyn Nets
    $11.7

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.