Reviews
What Dove C likes about Butterfly Café:
My husband and I are always wary going to a resort for dinner but we gave it a shot and were pleasantly surprised. Our waiter was calm attentive and wonderful. We sat outside and had a beautiful (and bug free! views. We started with a round of espresso martinis which were made perfectly with no dairy. I had the crab cakes to start which were so flavorful and might be the best I’ve had in marathon. I then had the scal... View all feedback. What DonnaM doesn't like about Butterfly Café:
The service was terrible! It was extremely disappointing for a high end , sophisticated restaurant. I did talk to the manager and he took the gratuity iff, as well as 15 of the bill. It could have been a great experience, but unfortunately it really put a damper on on our evening. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Unbelievable meal with an extremely attentive and smart waitress. Party of 10 was a piece of cake for her. One of the best upper scale restaurants in the Keys.
Butterfly Cafe was a sad disappointment from the start. We arrived 30 minutes early to check in and have drinks at the bar outside before our reservation. We wa...
read moreI love the decor of the place. The service was outstanding and the food was good. Appears large groups love dinner here. My only challenge was the Mojito I orde...
read moreBeautiful setting. We sat outside and the table and scenery were amazing! The service was very friendly and catering. Food was delicious! Highly recommend the w...
read moreA hidden gem! The Butterfly Cafe had great good, service and view. The view from the beach was beautiful and the dining area was quaint and calming. Our servers...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more