Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Scott Lawrence likes about Donatello's:
Very interesting vibe here and family owned/run. Like a classic pizza joint from the 80s. Service is fast and friendly roving staff member who checks in on you to make sure you are taken care of. The prices are very good $11 for a personal pepperoni fresh off the press. Pizza is a good quality thin crust. The place is clean and obviously well taken care of. Lots of families here but that is a good sign. Quite probabl... View all feedback.
What Sandra Martinez doesn't like about Donatello's:
Pizza was ok. The subs were not at all worth the money. We got a sub that smelled like rotten meat and fish. The chicken tenders were horrible and burnt like they were days old. Very dry and tasted like unflavored gummies. The fries were tasteless. I do not recommend this place at all. It was a negative 1 from me and my family. View all feedback.
One of the few places my family and I found open on a weekday but I can't believe they closed at 7 pm and stopped taking orders at 6:30! This pizza was really good. I'm glad my family and I found this place while staying in Niagara Falls. I wanted a sit down restaurant though and this place was better for takeout than it was to sit down with the family. The booth seats and tables to eat on were very small. We decided to take the pizza with us back to the hotel room. If you're looking for a nice sit down pizza place this isn't it, but if you just want real good pizza I highly recommend this place! The staff was very friendly which is big to me too.
read moreThe staff is so friendly and service was pretty quick. The pizza is delicious 10/10 enjoyed this small restaurant and it was cute seeing all the ninja turtle decorations! Definitely recommend if you need a bite to eat the chef salad was also excellent
read moreWe came when the place ended in 20 minutes. it was 2 hours before the posted hours, but they were short workers. we said we could only command. we have starved, so we have ordered and waited our cakes. then the owner came and spoke with our party of 16...6 narrow countries and 10 of our amish friends (what a crew! he had to close us in the past, let them sit us, brought us drinks, serviettes, teller and even a cool puzzle for all to solve. he chatted and made us feel so welcome, even at his conclusion. we were so tired (we had 7 miles on the day turned around the storm) and the cake. we had a basic cheese, a pfefferoni, the smell and a white pizza with huh. loaded with toppings and so tasty. and it was also very cold to breakfast! will definitely come back when we get up again. recommend for service and eating!
read moreThis place is always amazing. We travel from KY to NY usually once a year and we ALWAYS make sure to stop at Donatello's each trip. Nice location, great service and AMAZING food!
Pizza was great. Employees were very nice. Action said they were happy to have us.