Reviews
What Lizzie Murazik doesn't like about Gus's New York Pizza:
Bad Bad Bad experience. Having a going away party for our neighbor, So every one came over to wish them well. I ordered the 32 pizza from GUS'S to feed 12 people. Picked up the pizza on time and when we started we found the bottom was burnt black. Called the restaurant and was told the manager was in a meeting. Never got a call back. Very embarrassing, people couldn't eat any of it except the few pieces in the middle... View all feedback. What Brookelyn Johnson likes about Gus's New York Pizza:
I waited an hour for delivery on a Wednesday night, which struck me as unusual. However, being from out of state and staying in a hotel, I decided to be patient—and I’m so glad I did! I ordered a large pizza topped with mushrooms, artichokes, ricotta cheese, and fresh garlic on a Sicilian crust. I also tried their fried cheese, served with a balsamic reduction and marinara sauce. It was the BEST PIZZA I've ever had!... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Grabbed a take out pizza from this joint. Staff was courteous and quick. The bar looked lively. The pizza was great but it isn't really a New York slice. We got...
read moreNever have had a problem here. Is there stuff on their menu I don't like, of course there is. I am picky but, it is not their fault. I love their pizzas, son lo...
read moreOnly ordered from here since it was the only pizza joint open at 1am. I placed my order over the phone in which nothing could be heard, loud music in the backgr...
read moreMake sure your day is wide open before you come here because you will wait a long time. If you order via the phone or online, make sure that your...
I highly recommend this place! The pizza, wings and garlic knots are bomb. I want to go back and try more food because there are so many possibilities. It was.....
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreFood was excellent, service exceptional We tried the wings, pizza, baked ziti, Mac and cheese, spaghetti and meatballs and the bread knots. Everything tasted h...
read moreFirst time at this location and hands-down one of the best spots I’ve been to yet, extremely friendly service phenomenal food and atmosphere will definitely mak...
read moreExcellent pizza, and that's coming from someone who just moved here from New Jersey!!!! If you're looking for a good east coast style pizza, this is the place.....
read moreI waited an hour for delivery on a Wednesday night, which struck me as unusual. However, being from out of state and staying in a hotel, I decided to be patient...
read moreI visited NYPD Pizza for Father's Day, where they offer fathers a complimentary 8-inch pizza. We ordered a large Brooklyn family pizza, upstate wings, two of th...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreBad Bad Bad experience. Having a going away party for our neighbor, So every one came over to wish them well. I ordered the 32 pizza from GUS'S to feed 12 peopl...
read moreGreat place. Great customer service our server was extremely friendly. My guess is that she may have had something to do with owning the place but she was super...
read moreThe server was extremely courteous and checked on us frequently to ensure we had everything we needed. There were plenty of TVs for watching sports, and the bar...
read moreI only ordered from here because it was the only pizza place open at 1 AM. I called in my order, but I could barely be heard over the loud music in the backgrou...
read moreI ordered a takeout pizza from this place. The staff were friendly and quick with service. The bar had a lively atmosphere. The pizza itself was great, although...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more