Catelli's - GEYSERVILLE

Gotta try those guy fieri restaurant suggestions. Drove here while staying in Occidental and it was a treat. The minestrone soup was awesome. The ambiance was q... read more Gotta try those guy fieri restaurant suggestions. Drove here while staying in Occidental and it was a treat. The minestrone soup was awesome. The ambiance was quaint. The staff was so friendly and you felt like part of the in crowd. Large portions and the person that took our order new every detail of what you ordered. I did see the owner and was star struck and didn't get any photos of her.

For years, this was always a 5 star experience for both food and service. We went for dinner on Wednesday, June 22, 2022 and honestly if that was the first time... read more For years, this was always a 5 star experience for both food and service. We went for dinner on Wednesday, June 22, 2022 and honestly if that was the first time we went there we would never have gone back. We were seated and it took forever for wait staff to greet us. We ordered and the food also took much longer than normal. When my pasta dish arrived, it was prepared differently than normal. The pasta to sauce ratio was different and the flavors weren?t what they normally are. We ordered a dessert to share and after more than 15 minutes asked what the delay was. The manager came over and apologized and said they accepted a large party of 17 for the Rafanellis without a reservation and that affected everything. No offer to expedite the dessert or anything else. So, we asked for our check and left. I?m not sure that I will be back. And, I?m a little sad about that. What was a consistently wonderful experience became a serious disappointment on all fronts, service and quality of food.

Great food and service. Every dish ordered was tasty and definitely would recommend this spot if visiting Sonoma, was perfect after wine tasting to complete wit... read more Great food and service. Every dish ordered was tasty and definitely would recommend this spot if visiting Sonoma, was perfect after wine tasting to complete with an excellent meal.

Absolutely amazing Italian cuisine (sorry for the excitement, but it truly is incredible). The ravioli is handmade fresh daily. I tried their Lamb Cheese Raviol... read more Absolutely amazing Italian cuisine (sorry for the excitement, but it truly is incredible). The ravioli is handmade fresh daily. I tried their Lamb Cheese Ravioli and it was absolutely delicious! They added a unique touch to their lasagna by incorporating a hint of goat cheese. We were pleasantly surprised by the fantastic flavors. They cultivate their own herbs on the spacious back patio. The staff treated us like long-time friends and even remembered our names. It felt like a cozy gathering with loved ones. Dining on their patio is a delightful experience.

My husband and I chose to celebrate our wedding anniversary at Catelli's, and it turned out to be an excellent decision. The food, service, and ambiance were al... read more My husband and I chose to celebrate our wedding anniversary at Catelli's, and it turned out to be an excellent decision. The food, service, and ambiance were all outstanding. We both agreed that our experience, especially with our waitress Tiffany, was the best we had ever had at a restaurant. The Minestrone soup was the finest I’ve ever tasted, and my husband’s steak was cooked to perfection. I had the butter pasta with meatballs, which I was initially a bit unsure about, but it was delicious. Be sure to try the Affogato for dessert – it’s a must! We will certainly be returning to Catelli's soon.