Reviews - 1863
Reviews summary
Nestled within a hotel, this restaurant has garnered mixed reviews from patrons, with opinions on food, service, and atmosphere varying widely. While some diners rave about exceptional dishes like the Calamari and Filet, praising fresh ingredients and meticulous presentation, others find the food overpriced and service lacking. Notable server experiences highlight excellence, with staff members showcasing professionalism and warmth, while inconsistent service leaves some disappointed. Despite its prime location, many suggest exploring dining options outside the hotel to enhance the culinary experience. For a blend of history and flavor, it’s recommended to visit, particularly during quieter times for a more enjoyable meal.
Was Anthony at 1863 a mag?
Chelsea is the best; she provides great service and is a kind person. She is great at her job and we hope the restaurant keeps her at all costs. We will definitely be back to see her and enjoy this wonderful place. The food, service, and atmosphere all deserve a perfect rating of 5. View all feedback.
What D Smith dislikes about 1863:
Good food, but extremely expensive. Horrible service based on two encounters. Unfriendly and unhelpful staff. Absolutely do not go out of your way to go here. And if you’re staying at the Wyndham, you would be best served by driving somewhere else. Food: 4 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3 View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 02.09.2024
This restaurant is mediocre, with food that is just okay, but far from great. I normally wouldn't write a review for an experience as bland as this, but Google Maps suggested it to me while I was in Gettysburg. I regret not going somewhere else instead. The issue is not so much the quality, which is low but passable. The real problem is the lack of uniqueness in this restaurant, clearly designed by a team of specialists focused on creating a generic dining experience for the masses. It's an acceptable choice if you're staying at the hotel and don't have other options, but I would not recommend it otherwise. Vegetarian options are limited to a disappointing vegan burger, a few salads, and an afterthought.
Last update : 05.08.2024
Years ago this was the the place to go for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. The price reflected the quality and it was special. It was worth every penny. Emphasis on was. We made reservations in advance for Valentines. We waited in the...
Tania's Cosmo is amazing and perfect for a relaxing stay. If you're hungry, I recommend trying the pulled pork sandwich. The calamari is also delicious!
Tanya is the best bartender in the world. Bombarded by over a hundred unexpected attendees and flawlessly giving 110% to everyone. Still receiving my beautiful Negroni with a smile…
Tonya was an awesome bartender. Very professional and fun!!! I would definitely return if she is behind the bar
The hotel bar has a limited selection good beer and top shelf liquor. It can get busy when large groups book the hotel. The highlight of the bar is the bartender, Tania. She is a consummate professional and handles an overwhelming crowd with grace, skill, humor.
Last update : 25.11.2023
Food: 1 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 2
The restaurant offers excellent service and delicious food. It is located within a hotel. The food quality, service, and atmosphere all receive a high rating of 5.
This restaurant, located conveniently within the hotel, offers good food and excellent service. The dinner menu ranges in price from $20 to $30 per person. The food is rated 4 out of 5, the service a perfect 5, and the atmosphere a 4. Highly recommended dishes include the Calamari and the Fish and Chips.
Chelsea is the best; she provides great service and is a kind person. She is great at her job and we hope the restaurant keeps her at all costs. We will definitely be back to see her and enjoy this wonderful place. The food, service, and atmosphere all deserve a perfect rating of 5.
Good food, but extremely expensive. Horrible service based on two encounters. Unfriendly and unhelpful staff. Absolutely do not go out of your way to go here. And if you’re staying at the Wyndham, you would be best served by driving somewhere else. Food: 4 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 3
Last update : 21.04.2023
Wonder food and superior service. A must stop if you're in Gettysburg!
We sat near the bar and Zach the bartender took care of us. Extremely understandable about menu and drinks. Excellent service and the food was on point. We come up once a year and you are never disappointed! See you next year!
This is a very nice place. That being said, our experience was not as good as we would have liked. I made a reservation a week ahead of time. When we got there, there was no reservation. Fortunately they were able to seat us. I believe there was a large group in another area. We were told the kitchen was a little backed up. Understandable. We both ordered the steak cooked the same way. Unfortunately we got our steaks cooked completely different. I would go back perhaps at a quieter time.
We had a party of 8 and Nicole while training Jess was still on the game and did an amazing job. Good job! We loved it.
Stopped here at 1pm, had the place to ourselves! Very elegant carefully plated dishes. Atmosphere is still very casual. Crab lunch entree cake was great. We loved the solitude but they deserve more traffic from non-hotel patrons. Service was so polite.
