Cellar - Georgetown

#22 - Seafood - Georgetown, Pizza, International
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Cellar.

Cellar

Cellar
3.6 / 5 (37 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Cellar in Georgetown. At the moment, there are 41 dishes and drinks on the list.

The reviews for The Cellar restaurant in Georgetown, Ontario are mixed, with some customers expressing disappointment in the new menu introduced by the new owners. Complaints included long wait times, cold food, and dishes that were not up to par. One customer mentioned feeling let down by the removal of popular menu items like steak and lobster platters. However, others praised the quality of the food, particularly the steaks and seafood dishes. Positive comments touched on the cozy atmosphere, extensive wine selection, and exceptional service provided by the staff. Overall, opinions varied on the experience at The Cellar, with some recommending it for a special occasion, while others were left underwhelmed.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lorie

Images

Cellar Food Cellar Food Cellar Logo Cellar Food Cellar Food Cellar Inside Cellar Food Cellar Food

Reservation request for Cellar

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 37 reviews

Was Dariana Turner at Cellar a mag?
I have dined here in the past, so it was interested to review it again under the new property. She refreshed the interior. Some of the same menu items, but many new things to try. I went to lunch, and there were always great things to choose, and everything was delicious. View all feedback.

What Cindy Rosset dislikes about Cellar:
Spent $180+ for 2 people. Food was cold. A beta fish in a bowl under the Shrimp Cocktail (?! ugh). Plus, freezing in the restaurant! NO. Waitress forgot we ordered an expensive bottle of wine, came to ask us for wine order? Sorry, food was boring: 10oz NY cold, only salt on new potatoes, 1 asparagus spear, 2 pepper slices, bok choy... yawn. Did I mention the Beta Fish in the bowl under the Appie? Do not recommend. View all feedback.

m-wunder
21.03.2024

Can you keep a secret? Best meal I have had from any restaurant in many years. Cozy atmosphere, great presentation, fantastic service, and the food was exceptional. This past week six of us celebrated my nieces 30th birthday. Everyone commented on the taste and quality of their meals and how enjoyable the experience was.The new chef has upped the level of taste for the restaurant as every was dish prepared, presented and served with care and would surpass most high end restaurants.We will definitely return. Thankyou “The Cellar” for the great memories.

jay-smith-library59
21.03.2024

Arrived for reservation at 7 pm. Finally got food at 815 pm. Server was nice and polite. Kitchen slow.Food was not edible. Steak was shoe leather and not seasoning Fries soggy. Raviloi was swimming in some liquid. Ceasar salad was bitter. We didnt pay for mains as they were sent back. Horrible experience.

jess-l-bird0
21.03.2024

Just went to the cellar for a girls night dinner. We ordered many apps and all of them were fantastic. The mushroom app, the Brie and fish cake omg sooo good we also did the pre fix menu. My steak was cooked perfectly and my mashed potato was exquisite! like I’ve made some mean mashed potatoes but not like this.. the way it’s made is perfection. I had the most original cheesecake for dessert (baklava) and it really was outstanding. Super impressed and I’mUsually the biggest critique of places. I have nothing bad to say! the girls and I had a lovely time and enjoyed the food so much. Staff was welcoming and pleasant. Prices are so fair cant wait to come again.

lorie-manley-1
21.03.2024

Dinner for 6 of us and everyone loved their meals. Beautiful presentation and very flavourful. Outstanding service as well a wonderful evening.

mikebo2101ky
21.03.2024

5 of us had dinner at The Cellar in Georgetown on Friday February 3rd. A very unique place with good atmosphere. We were greeted by a nice young lady who offered to hang up our coats and were shown to our table. It was our first visit. Everyone enjoyed the food and drinks. Allison, our server was very friendly, helpful, and attentive. We will return and also reccomend this place to our friends, including my son in law who is an executive chef......Mike B.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.