Nautilus Cafe - Freeport

#18 - Seafood - Freeport, Steak, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Nautilus Cafe.

Nautilus Cafe

Nautilus Cafe
4.5 / 5 (4396 reviews)

Description

Nautilus Cafe in Freeport, NY, is a renowned American restaurant with an impressive average rating of 4.4 stars. Customers are encouraged to call ahead at (516) 379-2566 to secure a reservation and avoid long waits. If you prefer to dine at home, you can conveniently order your favorite dishes through OpenTable. The cafe is family-friendly, making it a great spot for kids. If you're intrigued by the menu but seeking more options, consider exploring nearby establishments like Captain Lou Fleet and Puerto Plata Seafood On The Water. Have you experienced dining at Nautilus Cafe? Share your thoughts and help fellow diners by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Cherishe

Reservation request for Nautilus Cafe

Submit Reservation Request

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 4396 reviews
cherishe-cumma-clark-6
07.04.2025

On Sunday August 7th,2022 my family and I visited Nautilus Cafe for the first time. We initially planned on going Bayview on the Mile but after reading the reviews for Nautilus Cafe we decided that this restaurant was more suitable to our needs. The dinningexperience was unlike anything that I ever experienced. Not only was the hostess willing to accommodate my extremely largereservation for 13 people but the staff provided excellent service. Recently I was diagnosed with gluten intolerance which asyou can imagine has made dinning outside of my home a bit complex. Fortunately for me we were served by the head waiter who wasextremely knowledgeable about the gluten-free options that were available. The head waiter along with his staff made my familyfeel welcome and catered to our every need. Everyone in my family raved at how impeccable the food was and how the quality ofthe food was well worth the price we paid. The Nautilus Cafe is an absolutely outstanding restaurant and I will be returningvery soon.

roger-reid-flower584
07.04.2025

My favorite restaurant. Very consistent, comfortable, fresh quality food, great attentive but not overbearing wait staff. Great bartender for years. And you can actually talk to each other without strain. All around quality dining.

iris-turcios
07.04.2025

I walked into the restaurant and I wasn’t welcomed when I came in waited and the hostess told us to wait and then asked the people behind if they had a reservation which overall I thought the hostess was rather rude because at least I would havewelcomed the next people that waited. I’m not sure if it was because we were Hispanic and the people behind us were white shethen decided to tell us that she took them first because they had a reservation. She was welcoming and nice to the people behindus.

nick
07.04.2025

Best restaurant on the Nautica Mile! Mouthwatering specials, excellent steak cooked crispy and perfectly medium well. Calamari was to die for, and Chocolate Lava Cake and Lime Cake where just exquisite, and tasted fresh. Our waitress (not sure of her namebut she had blonde hair and glasses) Was very polite and funny. DEFINITELY COMING BACK!

ellen-laperna
07.04.2025

Had a very nice time. I only wish they had dinner options that included a salad, starch and vegetable. All options were Ala Carte which brings the bill up substantially. Excellent service. Thank you. Happy Holidays.

FAQ

You can use the WLAN of the restaurant at no extra cost.

The eatery is a non-smoking restaurant.

The place also offers gluten-free dishes.

The restaurant also takes credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.