Lighthouse Cafe - Freeport

We had made the mistake of not checking our options on Briar Island for lunch. They are the only option in town and I really had my fill of greasy food and seaf... read more We had made the mistake of not checking our options on Briar Island for lunch. They are the only option in town and I really had my fill of greasy food and seafood by that point. So if you are in the mood for that kind of food, it is okay, if not I suggest packing a lunch or doing takeout from Lavena's Catch Cafe on Long Island before getting on the ferry.

We had dinner here our first night and lunch on our second. Both times had great food (the breading on the fish and scallops was especially good) and also they... read more We had dinner here our first night and lunch on our second. Both times had great food (the breading on the fish and scallops was especially good) and also they had bins for compost and recycling which is always nice to see.

We were looking around the island saw the lighthouse Calf decided to try it for lunch We both had there fish sandwich and fry,s the fish was excellent and very... read more We were looking around the island saw the lighthouse Calf decided to try it for lunch We both had there fish sandwich and fry,s the fish was excellent and very fresh there fry,s were frozen but were done properly and quite good the restaurant area was very clean and service very good there is no question if we would go back Yes

The food here is really good but the fish portions are a bit small. The burger was great. All food comes with a large quantity of fries and lovely coleslaw. read more The food here is really good but the fish portions are a bit small. The burger was great. All food comes with a large quantity of fries and lovely coleslaw.

This restaurant is the only option for lunch and one of the few options for dinner. They offer a pound of fish and chips, but when inquiring about the amount of... read more This restaurant is the only option for lunch and one of the few options for dinner. They offer a pound of fish and chips, but when inquiring about the amount of fish, the response was unhelpful. The truth is that they serve haddock bits - dry fish in small pieces - with thick, hard fries. While there is a generous portion of fries, the price is not worth it. My wife ordered the fish salad, which was the worst salad she has ever had. It consisted of mostly iceberg lettuce instead of romaine, chunks of onions, one piece of tomato, and some coleslaw. You are given a pager to retrieve your order, which is placed on an open table for you to season with salt, pepper, and ketchup. There are no covers for the salads, so bring a bag or box if you are ordering for multiple people. If we return to the area, we will bring our own food as a family could go bankrupt trying to eat here for a weekend.