Reviews - Casey's
Reviews summary
An old-school Casey’s in Fowler serves dependable convenience-store classics and surprisingly excellent pizza, breakfast biscuits-and-gravy, chicken strips and soft-serve—especially when standout crew members run the kitchen. Clean, well-lit and budget-friendly with free parking and fast takeout, the shop’s charm is undermined by chronic understaffing, spotty management, forgotten orders and unreliable online/phone ordering. Diners praise friendly employees and tasty treats, but experiences vary wildly by shift; visit when known cooks are working for the best results.
Was Jaron McMullin at Casey's a mag?
Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Sausage Pizza Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free parking lot View all feedback.
What John Cooper dislikes about Casey's:
The place is pretty much a joke, they have a few really great employees but I can tell that the store manager is worthless... always under staff especially on the nights and weekends! View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 28.02.2025
Robert was our chef, and the food was fantastic! We didn't have to wait long at all. I would definitely recommend this place while Robert is working. Service: Takeout Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20
This convenience store is excellent! It's friendly, clean, and well-lit. The food is consistently hot, especially the delicious pizza they make. I particularly enjoy the chicken strips they offer. In the mornings, their biscuits and gravy are a favorite of mine. They also have great lunch deals that include fountain drinks with sandwiches, helping you save some money. You can get a sub, chips, and a drink at a reasonable price. Those chocolate chip cookies at the register are hard to resist—they're really tasty! While I was there, I also noticed that the restrooms were very clean, which is a plus. I highly recommend Casey's for ice cream too; they have a soft serve machine! Whether you choose a cone or a cup, chocolate or vanilla—or go for a twist—it's a perfect treat for those hot summer days.
Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Sausage Pizza Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free parking lot
I don’t know what’s going on at Casey’s in Fowler but this was the worst pizza I’ve ever had from them so hard I could cut the roof of my mouth!! Will not be going back! Would rather drive to kentland and get pizza instead! Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1
If we could get the drug addicts out of there and hire people that would do their jobs I think everyone in town would really appreciate it!!! Update. This store constantly turns off online ordering and no one ever answers the phone. But they have time to sit on the phone in the managers office at complain about their jobs
Last update : 28.02.2025
For the second time in about a month, I went to Casey’s to pick up my pizza after 25 minutes, only to find that they hadn't even started my order. After waiting an additional 20 minutes, I canceled my order and left empty-handed to return to my family. Until they realize they need to hire more staff during dinner hours, I’ll be enjoying pizza from Fowler’s Pizza King instead. The management at this store is doing a poor job by scheduling only two employees during such a busy time.
