Casey's - Forsyth

#22 - Pizza - Forsyth, Breakfast, Lunch

Casey's

Casey's
4.2 / 5 (551 reviews)

Description

Part neighborhood convenience store and popular pizza spot, this Casey’s is praised for tasty pizzas, sandwiches, late‑night hours, delivery and clean restrooms with free parking and a rewards app. Many guests enjoy friendly, helpful service and on‑time delivery, but experiences are uneven: some report rude or inattentive staff, slow pump activation, stock shortages during promotions, and occasional order or preparation issues. Overall it’s a convenient, budget‑friendly stop with solid food but inconsistent service and management.

Last update: 20.03.2026 from: Rogue

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 551 reviews
eprice-chef275
12.05.2023

The restaurant is always clean, and the staff is consistently friendly. I really enjoy the sandwiches, which are delicious, and the pizza is usually quite good as well. The restrooms are very clean—the last time I used them, at least. I also appreciate the rewards app they offer. My only complaint is that it's not uncommon to find them out of stock on items during special one-day promotions. I understand it's a first-come, first-served situation, but if you go at 8:00 AM and they're already sold out, it’s a bit disappointing. I'm not sure if Casey has their managers on top of this or if it's more of a company-wide issue. Regardless, I think if there’s a sale or a special offer, they should have enough stock to last throughout the day.

tumelo19
12.05.2023

At Casey's ordering process for pizza and other items was a nice experience. They were very patient and helpful in my ordering process and very realistic about the delivery time based on their current volume. The delivery person is very friendly and very friendly with a very positive attitude and made the entire experience to the last bite LOL pleasant!

hassie06
12.05.2023

You have the cheapest gas in the area, with prices 5 cents lower than all the other gas stations. In addition to gas, you can also order delicious sub sandwiches, not just pizza. The staff is very friendly and attentive too.

rogue
01.03.2025

Fast service. Some pumps in need of repair.

cliff-rocha
01.03.2025

Shout out to Randal for making us the best pizza to date we have ever gotten to date from here.

FAQ

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.