Casey's - Forsyth

#22 - Pizza - Forsyth, Breakfast, Lunch

Casey's

Casey's
4.2 / 5 (551 reviews)

Description

Part neighborhood convenience store and popular pizza spot, this Casey’s is praised for tasty pizzas, sandwiches, late‑night hours, delivery and clean restrooms with free parking and a rewards app. Many guests enjoy friendly, helpful service and on‑time delivery, but experiences are uneven: some report rude or inattentive staff, slow pump activation, stock shortages during promotions, and occasional order or preparation issues. Overall it’s a convenient, budget‑friendly stop with solid food but inconsistent service and management.

Last update: 20.03.2026 from: Rogue

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 551 reviews
rogue
01.03.2025

Fast service. Some pumps in need of repair.

cliff-rocha
01.03.2025

Shout out to Randal for making us the best pizza to date we have ever gotten to date from here.

keely-knudson-dog24
01.03.2025

I am only giving this Casey's a one-star because I have to I would give it -3 Stars I was in there today on I believe this is Friday I'm not sure the manager was Brandy I called to talk to her about her staff I waited 15 minutes for breakfast bacon first off I asked the guy in the back with dark black greasy hair that should have a hair knot on because he has long hair hair net I would definitely want that I'm a regional manager at Hardee's and they would have them on I asked him very nicely is there going to be more breakfast pizza coming out he looked down and ignored me I said sir are there going to be more breakfast bacon and he goes like he Shrugged his shoulders and I said I would like to have some pizza some sorry some breakfast bacon pizza please he said okay like in the most like rudest voice possible they were too busy putting out pepperoni at 9 a.m. so I wait for 10 to 15 minutes doing shopping get myself some coffee getting some cookies for my husband for later waiting around set up against the thing got mustard that should have been wiped down by Brandy the sitting there laughing at it with every customer and not paying attention to her employees whatsoever she heard me tell the guy next to me how unhappy I was and that I did not want the pizza anymore cuz it was sausage and I asked for bacon she sat there and listened to this so then when I called back she was very rude to me and she hung up on me and told me she never talked to me Brandy needs a lesson in management and to stop flirting with the customers 100% she was flirting that's what she does in the morning I didn't see her doing anything else she could have been wiping down counters and then the little boy next to her just stands there at the register whoever owns his Casey's I would definitely be talking to Brandi I am a regional manager Hardee's and she would be fired she hung up on me when I tried to talk to her about it and I asked her for her regional manager and she said she didn't have one so I would get this girl in line immediately she yelled at me over the phone I am a customer I am always right and I was professional I would like Brandi fired

shawna-lacy
01.03.2025

Absolutely worst Casey's ever, they refuse to pay attention to the pumps, can't pay at the pump because they are too busy on their phones to turn the pumps on, absolutely cannot provide adequate customer service, they are the rudest people I have ever encountered and I've worked in the public for 20 years. I would NEVER recommend this store for anything other than a bathroom.

liadain-cox
01.03.2025

Been coming here since I was a kid and I’ve never had bad food or bad service! Of course the slushy machine does break down occasionally 10/10 Service: Takeaway Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Sausage Pizza, Doughnut Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free of charge parking lot

FAQ

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical disabilities.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.