Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about New York Pizza Fleming Island:
Here’s an authentic review! The pizza roll was huge—almost like a log—and it was simply amazing! The pizza was perfectly cooked, the French fries were big and full of flavor, and the garlic bread was fresh. However, the real highlight was undoubtedly the SUB! It was perfectly roasted, and each bite of the sandwich was a true delight. Additionally, the delivery was impressively quick, arriving around 25 minutes ahead... View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about New York Pizza Fleming Island:
Today, I ordered two pizzas: one cheese and one pepperoni. Unfortunately, I must say that the pepperoni pizza was quite disappointing. As a regular customer, I typically find something I enjoy, but today it was excessively greasy, and the crust was so thin that it was nearly transparent. To make matters worse, the flavor was awful, and the bottom of the box was soaked in grease. Sadly, I won't be ordering from here a... View all feedback.
Cold pizza is sad. Pick up order. You knew we were there but made us wait while the order got cold. Really cold. No. Never again. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 2
This is the best NY style pizza in Clay County without a doubt. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Not what ordered. Staff had bad attitude wish I never spent money there.
They only offer bottled drinks, charging $1.99 for a small bottle of Aquafina water. The drinks were taken straight from the fridge and weren't very cold, and I noticed they don't have an ice machine or provide cups. We could have used a few more plates, as they only gave us five flimsy paper plates for the five of us to share the salad, pizza, wings, and garlic bread. The plates were the cheapest type and were bending and leaking from the bottom. Overall, I would rate the food a 3, the service a 2, and the atmosphere a 2.
As a NYC transplant, I can honestly say this was a piece of home and the Sicilian was amazing. I will be back often!!! Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Full Menu
Soft Drinks
Pizza
Side Dishes
Sauces
More information
QR-code link to the menu
