Another Broken Egg Cafe - Fishers

Casual, Coffee & Tea, Cafe
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Another Broken Egg Cafe

Another Broken Egg Cafe
4.3 / 5 (462 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Another Broken Egg Cafe in Fishers. At the moment 35 dishes and drinks are on the menu.

Nestled in a charming locale, this restaurant has garnered mixed reviews from patrons. While the ambiance is warm and inviting, and the service friendly, the quality of food can be hit or miss. Signature dishes like the Shrimp and Grits and Banana French Toast shine, often praised for flavor and generous portions. However, some guests reported inconsistencies, such as burnt bacon and bland sides. Despite these shortcomings, the diverse menu and welcoming environment, complemented by gluten-free and vegan options, make it a potential brunch spot for those seeking variety. A visit may yield delicious surprises!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Tyrese

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 462 reviews

Was Nyx The V at Another Broken Egg Cafe a mag?
True to their word we did have a 45 minute wait. My dad ordered the Hash Brown Benidict, he finished the whole thing. My BF ordered their seasonal Banana French toast, this one was the best meal of the table....delicious, it was soft and flavorful. My lil one ordered French toast sampler, she finished the whole meal and she rarely eats everything. I ordered the Shrimp Benny. It came with alot of shrimps which I was s... View all feedback.

What Sadie O dislikes about Another Broken Egg Cafe:
Don’t bother with this place. The biscuit was burnt and dry, the bacon is supposed to be BAKED. This bacon was so greasy I didn’t even bother eating it. It left a massive grease puddle on my plate. The gravy is an odd texture and not very good and the potatoes are bland. Sausage was okay. Overall would not recommend unfortunately, considering their prices they should have better food. : View all feedback.

brett70
01.10.2023

This was my first visit to this restaurant and I was not disappointed. The atmosphere was charming and I really enjoyed the outdoor seating. The menu had a wide variety of options to choose from. I ultimately decided on the BLT with avocado and it was delicious! I also ordered a side of fruit, which included all of my favorite fruits - a pleasant surprise as I often have to pick and choose. I will definitely recommend this restaurant to others and plan on returning in the future.

antwan-rogahn
01.10.2023

We attended a bridal brunch at this restaurant and had a wonderful experience. The space was very nice, the food was delicious, and the service was friendly. The beignets were incredible and the omelets stood out because of the cream cheese base. There were plenty of drink options available, but we stuck with mimosas.

kourtney-n-1
01.10.2023

I absolutely love this restaurant for breakfast. The staff is incredibly friendly, the ambiance is cozy and welcoming, and the food is exceptional. My go-to dish is the city-style Shrimp and Grits with a side of buttermilk pancakes. My husband usually orders the chicken and biscuit breakfast sandwich, but this time he tried the supreme omelette without mushrooms and onions.

gheathcote-elephant0
01.10.2023

My wife and I love e this breakfast chain and stopped in while visiting the area recently. The restaurant is clean and fresh and the staff is engaging and friendly. Our party of 6 was seated relatively quickly, and our server was quick to get our order started. The food came quickly and was prepared to order. The coffee was rich and tasty (a great start), and the biscuits and gravey was top notch. A couple of the folks raved over the crab cake benedict, the spinach scramble was very good, and the bacon was thick and juicy. All in all, this location represents the brand very well, and we certainly stop back in the next time we are in the area. Highly recommend Another Broken Egg Cafe brand and this location.

becker-dashawn
01.10.2023

My daughter and I enjoyed brunch here today and LOVED every bite!! I had the Mardi Gras Omelet and she had a pound cake french toast with strawberries meal. Taylor was extraordinary and very attentive! We will be back!!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.