Captain D's - Findlay

#22 - Fast Food - Findlay, Delivery Services, Seafood
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Captain D's

Captain D's
4.0 / 5 (2508 reviews)

Description

A popular local spot known for friendly staff and ample parking has recently experienced inconsistent quality. While some patrons praise the fresh fish and attentive servers like Ramona and Shandi, others report undercooked, overcooked, or poorly prepared meals with occasional off-flavors and soggy textures. Service tends to fluctuate during busy, understaffed periods, sometimes accompanied by managerial issues. Despite these challenges, many appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and are hopeful improvements will continue. Frequent specials and coupon offers add value, making it a place worth trying, but diners are advised to temper expectations during peak times.

Last update: 12.07.2026 from: WILLIAM

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 2508 reviews
william-deiter
22.09.2023

I really enjoy going there because the food is excellent. We usually drive down from Toledo just to eat there. However, since we can no longer dine in the restaurant, we haven't been visiting at all. Unfortunately, we don't like eating in our car. We won't return until the dining room reopens.

quintarius-ross
22.09.2023

The service is excellent, and the staff is very friendly, making it a fantastic place to visit. Thank you!

deidre-ewing
22.09.2023

My initial experience at this restaurant was truly impressive. The person who assisted me with my order seemed genuinely happy in his role and was eager to share the various options available to me. He was very polite without being pushy, and he greeted me with a big smile when I arrived at the window. He also inquired about which dipping sauces I would like, ensuring that I had more than enough—quite a contrast to many other fast food places that always charge extra for everything. It was clear that he was passionate about his work, and it felt refreshing. I would definitely return; it was one of the best fast food experiences I've ever had!

martina65-2
10.02.2023

Manager was yelling at employees , ran out of food , as soon as you walked in the place you could smell the burnt oil from the fryers and the fish tasted like it too. Service counter employees were pleasant and doing the best they could. I would have just left but they already had my money and the chances I would get my money back before I got my food were slim....I will not be back. $15; wasted .I should have just given it to the bum waiting outside of McDonald's asking for donations down the street.

myriam30
10.02.2023

I'm usually a big fan of the Captain but today was different. When you pay $16+ for a meal you expect to get what you ordered and it be fresh as well. The catfish I ordered wasn't catfish and the cheese on the loaded potato was like faux leather or something. I also usually don't do reviews but it's better than returning to the store especially when you've gotten into your home on a 30° day. I'm not bashing at all, you just come to expect a lot better food served when you're spending basically $20 per person.

FAQ

There is a TV / screen on-site where sports events are broadcast.

The diner is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

The restaurant accepts various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.