Insomnia Cookies - Fayetteville

I witnessed a very unpleasant interaction with the server at this restaurant while with my boyfriend. He asked for two scoops of ice cream and a cookie but couldn't remember the flavors and was just inquiring about the price. When he finally decided what he wanted, the server (a woman whose name I didn't catch) rudely responded, "You have to tell me what you want first." I was shocked and appalled by how disrespectful she was. Even when my boyfriend thanked her for the ice cream, she completely ignored him. We probably won't be returning to this restaurant, and I only rated it 2 stars because my boyfriend enjoyed the ice cream and cookie. ??

The snickerdoodle cookie had an unpleasant taste resembling rotten eggs. The salted caramel dessert was enjoyable, but the staff was somewhat impolite.

The restaurant review was a great birthday present and a thoughtful way to show love to my college granddaughter! It was delivered right to her door on her birthday.

I have been ordering from them for the past 5 years to send to my kids in college and they always do a great job! Deliveries are on time and cookies are always great!

Bring a friend or be ready to gorge yourself on one of the best ice cream cookie sandwich you will ever have. Really high quality ice cream is sandwiched between 2 freshly baked cookies of your choice. Awesome.