Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Mack Labadie likes about Brooklyn Pizzeria:
White pizza and meat lover pizza are fantastic. We bought the 16in and had enough left over for lunch and dinner the next day. Authentic pizza for anyone new to the area. View all feedback.
What Monica Primus doesn't like about Brooklyn Pizzeria:
Glad they are open so I can get the Stromboli. I just turned my 85 year old father-in-law onto this place. I couldn 't believe he had never been here since he has lived in Fayetteville since the '60s. He was shocked at the size of the pie; said he had never seen one so big; I got an 18 inch. Now he won 't eat pizza from anywhere else! View all feedback.
Delicious menu available at a friendly neighborhood location. Definitely recommend it to anyone that enjoys NY style pizza.
I'm glad this restaurant is open because I can get the Stromboli. I just introduced my 85-year-old father-in-law to this place, and I couldn't believe he had never been here, especially since he has lived in Fayetteville since the '60s. He was amazed by the size of the pie and exclaimed that he had never seen one that big before—I ordered an 18-inch! Now he refuses to eat pizza from anywhere else!
Delicious! The portion sizes are fantastic, and the meatballs are incredibly tasty. This is definitely my go-to favorite!
This is NY style pizza at its best. Thin crust is crusty, toppings add flavor and not heaviness, just enough sauce to taste. If you you've had NY style pizza, this is close as you'll get without leaving the state.
I’m a bit of a NY style pizza snob and this is THE best we have had in this area by far!
Full Menu
Download Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
