Croxley's Public House Garden

Croxley's is a great sports bar to grab a beer, wings and watch the game. Their wings are usually great, but can be a bit dry on occasion. Their other food seems like a bunch of frozen items so I would avoid pretty much anything aside from their wings.

First they wanted to put us in a corner where you can't see the tv's. They didn't want to move us! We had a reservation for 6 men at 7:00. What the heck did they think we wanted to do???? But the TV did t even have the local hockey game. Instead they had 2 teams from another area! We ordered wings. The main portion was supposed to be put under crisper and the other smaller order regular. They can put opposite of what we ordered. I had to ask 3x for a frosted mug! We had to ask multiple times for napkins and water! The food was nothing special by far. Your basic burgers or French dip. My dip was dry and not very good. They can do a lot better!

Not my typical scene but I’ve never really been disappointed here. Good drinks, good food. A little crowded at times but that’s probably the old man in me talking. A definite win for Farmingdale.

Pros: Pumpkin beer AND a cinnamon sugar rim. They don't do that here in Virginia so it's always a nice treat when we visit Croxley's. Food is good and consistent, the wings were crispy and the zucchini fries were well flavored. I knock a star off because they were drilling inside the restaurant (right next to our table) for 10 minutes and it was hard to even hear the person sitting next to me. And another star because we couldn't find our waitress or any other staff other than bartender for awhile (we later discovered she was being trained on the POS system). We did go at an off time (around 2pm) so perhaps why these things were happening.

I came here when visiting family and enjoyed my meal! The Bavarian pretzel was a bit salty, it would've tasted a bit better without so much salt but I rubbed it off and all was well. I got the wings since that's what they're known for and enjoyed both the flavors I got. I'd rate the pulled pork tacos a 2.5/5. I think if there was a bbq drizzle on top that would've been good. They're a bit drippy.