Pie Pan - Evansville

Breakfast-brunch, American, Delivery
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Pie Pan

Pie Pan
3.7 / 5 (2276 reviews)

Menu

On this webpage, you will find the complete menu of Pie Pan from Evansville. Currently, there are 134 dishes and drinks available.

The Pie Pan presents a culinary conundrum, delighting patrons with excellent food yet facing hurdles in service consistency. Diners rave about standout dishes, from mouthwatering country fried steak to highly praised pies, while others lament cold soups and questionable hygiene practices. Service quality appears to fluctuate, with some guests enjoying attentive waitstaff and others encountering distractions and delays. A recent ambiance transformation has altered the restaurant's character, though many patrons still appreciate the friendly staff and speedy service. Despite the disparity in experiences, The Pie Pan remains a beloved spot for satisfying meals at affordable prices.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Paul

Images

Pie Pan Food Pie Pan Food Pie Pan Food Pie Pan Food Pie Pan Drink Pie Pan Menu Pie Pan Food Pie Pan Menu

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 2276 reviews

Was Anonym at Pie Pan a mag?
I had the breakfast sandwich with bacon, egg, and cheese, along with a side of hashbrown casserole. It was absolutely delicious! The server provided excellent service and I will definitely be back soon! View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Pie Pan:
Arrived at 10:35 and requested a table for two adults with a high chair. Sat in a corner booth near the kitchen for 20 minutes without being acknowledged, spoken to, or provided with the high chair. The server assigned to us seemed more focused on leaving at 11 than attending to our needs, as she ignored another table near us and continued to our table only at 10:55, right before we decided to leave. We will not be r... View all feedback.

chad-burtsfield
16.03.2024

The food was very tasty. I ordered the country fried steak and it was delicious. My mom and sisters both had the roast beef and French dip sandwiches, and they also enjoyed their meals.

christy-masseur-2
16.03.2024

Don't go if you are already hungry because it's very slow here. It took about ten minutes for the Server to come out and tell me they're out of the item I ordered. Two little girls a boy repeatedly kept going in and out of the kitchen. We could hear our server their mom/the cook saying reprimands to them. No one brought us menus or silverware; finally my daughter got us some. Then, the server finally came and asked what we wanted to order. People who came in after us got their food before us. My salad was missing its croutons, and my husband's plate was missing its ranch cup. My kids drinks didn't come until I reminded her, and they never got a refill. It took almost an hour inside before we got our food. It caused us to completely miss the time we were supposed to arrive somewhere.

bill-carolyn-carrie-
16.03.2024

The food at this restaurant is delicious and the staff is friendly. The restaurant itself is clean, including the restrooms.

paul-duncan-fox97
16.03.2024

Very good service and not at all wanting time

kaitlyn-tubbs
16.03.2024

There was only one waitress, poor thing. She was awesome, but someone must have called in and left her there on her own. I got the chicken and waffles and the waffle was good but the chicken left something to be desired. It wasn't bad just mid.

  • Soups

    Pie Pan Soup
    Pie Pan Soup
  • Sides

    Pie Pan's Sweet Potato Casserole
    Pie Pan's Sweet Potato Casserole
  • Award Winning Breakfasts

    Libby's Special
    Libby's Special
  • Breakfast Sandwiches

    Tag-A-Longs Breakfast Sandwich
    Tag-A-Longs Breakfast Sandwich
    Tag-A-Longs Breakfast Sandwich On Croissant
    Tag-A-Longs Breakfast Sandwich On Croissant
  • Three Egg Omelettes

    Big Country Omelette
    Big Country Omelette

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.