The Cellar - Evanston

#13 - Seafood - Evanston, Global, International
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for The Cellar.

The Cellar

The Cellar
4.1 / 5 (2830 reviews)

Menu

The menu of The Cellar from Evanston contains about 163 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $9.3 for a dish / drink.

The Cellar restaurant in Evanston offers a pleasant dining experience with good food and friendly service. While some dishes like the scallops and stuffed shrimp were enjoyed by guests, others like the overdone salmon and lackluster lobster bisque fell short. The atmosphere was cozy and the bartenders were attentive, but some guests found the restaurant to be a bit chilly, especially near the windows. Overall, The Cellar seems to be a moderately priced option with potential for improvement in consistency and attentiveness to guest comfort.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: DeniseH

Images

The Cellar Food The Cellar Food The Cellar Food The Cellar Food The Cellar Food The Cellar Food The Cellar Drink The Cellar Drink

Reservation request for The Cellar

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 2830 reviews

Was C B at The Cellar a mag?
I recently dined at The Cellar for the first time. The service was excellent, the kitchen was quick, and the food was pretty good. The ambiance wasn't my favorite, but that could have been because we were seated near the... View all feedback.

What Theo Muller dislikes about The Cellar:
I’ve been to the Cellar before. The menu has changed- less small plates, prices higher. My salmon was fine, but nothing special. Same for the burger. Disappointing experience. View all feedback.

dframi
07.04.2023

Great place in front of the theatre. Good value for food. Good wine list.

rdeckow
07.04.2023

My only complaint is that it was very cold.had to keep my jacket all the time. was close to a window and the wind came directly to the glass. I close the blind to stop the breeze and the staff has opened it again. They didn't seem to care that we were very cold. Others also had their coats, not just our table.

dominika82
07.04.2023

We like the cellar for a quick dinner. We just had a bad experience with our waiter wrong order and wrong items on our bill.

deniseh
17.08.2024

Great place before theatre. Good value for food. Good wine list.

hungryhippo
17.08.2024

My only complaint is that it was very cold..had to keep my jacket on the entire time.was near a window and breeze was coming right thru the glass. I shut the blind to stop the breeze and staff opened it again. They didn't seem to care that we were very cold. Other people had their coats on too, not just our table.

  • Drafts

    Begyle Brewing (Chicago)
    Begyle Brewing (Chicago)
    $8.0
    Revolution Brewing (Chicago)
    Revolution Brewing (Chicago)
    $8.0
  • Craft

    Sicilian Pink Lemonade (Rocks)
    Sicilian Pink Lemonade (Rocks)
    $10.0
    Irish Fling (Rocks)
    Irish Fling (Rocks)
    $11.0
    Mumbai Margarita (Rocks) (A Campfire Margarita)
    Mumbai Margarita (Rocks) (A Campfire Margarita)
    $12.0
    Hooray Henry! (Up)
    Hooray Henry! (Up)
    $13.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.