First Slice Pie Cafe - Evanston

#25 - Cafés - Evanston, American, Salad

First Slice Pie Cafe

4.4 / 5 (91 reviews)

Description

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Vanessa

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 91 reviews
vanessa-1158
09.09.2023

A wonderful new establishment in my neighborhood! It’s the perfect place to relax, get some work accomplished, and savor a delicious latte with a tasty snack. The next time you’re thinking about going to Starbucks, think about trying First Slice instead.

lisa-2662
09.09.2023

Best pie in the city!

raoul-turner
09.09.2023

The pie is amazing! On the other hand, some of the sandwiches could use a little work. Be sure to visit for the pie, and don't forget to enjoy the complimentary water while you're at it!

johnson-fredy
09.09.2023

The pies are excellent and the Hip Hop Salad is amazing.

gabriella33
09.09.2023

Hoosier Mamma stopped accepting Thanksgiving orders a month ago, but I discovered pies here that are just as good, if not better. They’ve got their logistics figured out too. If they had a slogan in Evanston, it could be, "Who's Your Pie Daddy?"

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR code for the menu of First Slice Pie Cafe

Suggested nearby restaurants.