Bennison's Bakery - Evanston

We bought the lamb cake for Easter. It was beautifully decorated. It didn't taste great. Dry and little taste. I expected more for $40. read more We bought the lamb cake for Easter. It was beautifully decorated. It didn't taste great. Dry and little taste. I expected more for $40.

If you are looking for a sweet treat and you are in Evanston, you definitely need to try Bennison's Bakery! The cookies, cakes, and breads are not only abundant... read more If you are looking for a sweet treat and you are in Evanston, you definitely need to try Bennison's Bakery! The cookies, cakes, and breads are not only abundant in kind, but delicious. It is smaller inside which promotes a quick trip. The staff are very kind, helpful, and efficient. Bennison's also has the most delicious (and my personal favorite) zimtsterne cookies during the Christmas season. Though it's only a seasonal option, I do wait all year long for these cookies!

Local, known, historic, family-owned, community serving and beloved Evanston bakery. Worth the trip north for Chicagoland folks, especially during MartyGras, Ea... read more Local, known, historic, family-owned, community serving and beloved Evanston bakery. Worth the trip north for Chicagoland folks, especially during MartyGras, EasterSunday, Christmas specialty baked goods search. Make sure to call in those specialty orders in advance. Bakery ovens and bakers on premise, right next door, stand at the window and say hi to the bakers.The staff are young, knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. The ambiance is family oriented.The pastries, cookies, donuts, pies, muffins are all fresh and flavorful but my favorite is the BEE-STING. The piece is huge with a mouse filling, toffee-honey toping sandwiched by moist creamy cake.I love this place!!!

I visited Bennison's after noticing their eye-catching classic neon sign on the corner. The bakery boasts an impressive variety of breads, cakes, cookies, and p... read more I visited Bennison's after noticing their eye-catching classic neon sign on the corner. The bakery boasts an impressive variety of breads, cakes, cookies, and pastries. I decided to try a 6-pack of cheddar scallion biscuits, which were absolutely delicious when warmed up, along with some Italian cookies. Everything was fantastic, and I will definitely return!

I've known this bakery since the 1970s, and it still delivers the same greatness it did back then. The carrot cake is excellent, and the cannoli are absolutely... read more I've known this bakery since the 1970s, and it still delivers the same greatness it did back then. The carrot cake is excellent, and the cannoli are absolutely amazing—they fill them to order, keeping the outside perfectly crunchy. The service is also very friendly.