Udder Choice - Ephrata

American, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Food
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Udder Choice

Udder Choice
4.5 / 5 (369 reviews)

Description

Welcome to The Udder Choice! Locally owned and family operated since 1989, The Udder Choice has long been a favorite with the locals and is a must-visit location for those passing through the Lancaster area. Located in a barn-like building, customers are made to feel like part of the family, greeted with friendly service, and amazing homemade food. From breakfast to lunch to dinner, we are committed to serving you the very best. Our food is prepared fresh daily, and we also offer daily specials. And if you are an ice cream lover, you will be thrilled with our flavors and variations. Homemade on the premises, our flavor selection rotates regularly. Come visit us at 1812 W. Main Street, Ephrata, PA 17522, or give us a call at 717-733-4300. Our hours are Monday-Saturday 5:30AM-9PM, Sunday 2PM-9PM. We can't wait to welcome you!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Michel

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 369 reviews
michel-galante
26.10.2024

Corn chowder soup is delicious. Sloppy Joe was very good as well. It was a little noisy when I went, but overall, it was a great place.

jennifer-barnes-jenn
26.10.2024

It was okay, felt rushed the whole time. Food was okay at best in my opinion. Parking: Plenty of parking in parking lot Kid-friendliness: Kid-friendly Wheelchair accessibility: No steps

terri-powell-4
26.10.2024

Love Udder Choice! My husband and I go there every time we’re down that way. Soups, sandwiches, everything is great. Except this time when I ordered a Vanilla Coke, which I always get there and look forward to, it didn’t taste right. Tasted like a cherry coke which I do not like. Told the waitress and she brought me another. Same thing. I didn’t want to bug her again so I just let it go. But I was very disappointed. Hope it’s better next time.

max-zeuner-1
26.10.2024

We got milkshakes and ice cream and somehow ended up with ice cream flavored milk. Ice cream was still ice cream—but milkshakes were definitely not good.

jenna
26.10.2024

Don’t go just for the ice cream, it’s 100% not worth it. Both our milkshakes were just milk and a scoop of ice cream, so liquidy and barely could taste the ice cream flavor! The scoop of ice cream was freezer burnt and completely melted in minutes on a cool night. Service was subpar as well.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.