Casey's - Elida

Breakfast, Lunch, American

Casey's

Casey's
3.8 / 5 (141 reviews)

Description

Casey's in Elida, OH, is a delightful American restaurant that boasts an impressive average rating of 4 stars. With doors open from 5:00 AM to 11:00 PM, it's the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings any time of day. To ensure a seamless dining experience, consider calling ahead at (419) 221-2796 to reserve your table. For those with dietary preferences, Casey's also offers a variety of vegetarian options. If you're intrigued by the menu but want to explore similar choices, check out nearby eateries like Speedy Cafe and Happy Daz. After your visit, don't forget to share your thoughts by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Cassie

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 141 reviews
carla-rice
10.01.2024

9 times out of 10, the pumps can't provide a receipt. Pump #10 was out of order without a notice on the handles. The line inside is always slow, and today there was no one at the counter so I didn't get a receipt at all. I missed out on my Upside rebate thanks to that experience. I have a special needs child; it's a great hardship to go inside for a receipt.Great selection in the store and competitive prices, but I will stick with Meijer and Speedway from now on.

erin-shook
10.01.2024

It’s a nice gas station, and the store is clean, but I’m frustrated that they have the tap option on their gas pumps, yet have a sign next to it that says it’s not available yet. I didn’t have my card with me today, but figured it would be ok to wait to get gas at Casey’s, as they’re new. I figured since they’re a newer store, that they’d have the tap option available.I was a little annoyed that I had to go inside to pay, but it was fine, whatever. The tap option worked inside, thank goodness. However, when I asked about the tap option being outside on the pumps, as notated, they said not only did it not work, but that they would never have that option on the pumps. This makes NO sense. Why even show the option at all?? And for them to be so nonchalant about it, that they never intend on offering that, was ridiculous.To not offer that option, with so many people using it everywhere else, is frustrating. They need to get rid of it from the pumps so that the assumption isn’t even there. This is my first and last time I’ll be buying gas there.

michael-evans-2
10.01.2024

The gas was cheap for the area. That was nice.The washer reservoirs were empty. (One of the reasons I stopped was to clean my rear window. The pump was out of receipt paper. The restroom needed cleaned and was out of soap. I'm not going to buy any snacks when I can't wash my hands so I didn't try anything inside after that

cassie-snyder
08.05.2025

I love this store! It's always very clean and the workers are always so friendly.

amber-renee-flower94
08.05.2025

Food to go? Everyone time I have ordered it has been same employee who was not properly trained and is slow. Not her fault by any means! Clearly she was just thrown into the job without the tools knowledge she needed and she does the best she can!!!!

Menu

FAQ

The restaurant also takes various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.