O'neill's Pizza Pub - Elgin

We were in town for a boys' soccer game and O'Neills came up as a restaurant in the area. Great food selection and it was very tasty. Only minor issue was that the garden salad was a bowl of Iceberg lettuce with chopped tomato. Rest of the meal was great and staff were very attentive.

Great Minnesota thin crust pizza served by wonderful people.

I lived only 50 feet from this place for about 2 years and only ate there once. This is the only restaurant in Elgin too btw. I ordered a large supreme pizza and what I thought were buffalo chicken wings. I got the food only 10 minutes later and brought it home to eat. The pizza was literally just like a cheap paper thin crust frozen Jack 's and it honestly didn 't taste as good as a Jacks. The toppings were pathetic, diced tiny and had no flavor. The pizza was way overpriced for what you got and it was sad that a Pizza place would serve such bland pizza. The Chicken wings we 're disgusting! They were just 3 medium sized plain breaded chicken fingers that were obviously microwaved. The meat was dry and had tons of nasty looking cartilage and dark spots. I have no idea how this place has such a high rating on Google. Another smaller point to make is they are only open until 8:00pm on both Friday and Saturday night!

So glad to see this place resurrected! It was always a favorite in Rochester. We had the Greek pizza with gyro meat and it was EXACTLY as I remembered it, right down to way they make the crust, with the little folds around the outside. A real treat can’t wait to come back

Amazing pizza, great customer service, down home feel. I remember when this place was still located in Rochester, still the same awesome small town pizza joint.