Menu - Bennigan's
Menu
A complete overview of all 86 meals and beverages can be found here on the menu of Bennigan's from Elgin.
Menu
Soft Drinks
Bottle.
$4.0Hot Drinks
$4.0Beverages
$4.0$4.0Mix And Match Entrees
Oh Baby Back RibsSalads
$7.0Baby greens tossed + balsamic vinaigrette. Tomatoes; grilled onions; crispy mushrooms; housemade croutons; bleu cheese crumbles + 4 oz. of sliced marinated flat iron steak. Choose a meat preparation: Rare; Medium Rare.
$12.0$7.0
Ultimate Buffalo Chicken SaladA fresh combination of tender greens; carrots; celery; pico de gallo & bleu cheese crumbles served + ranch dressing. Top it + crispy / grilled Buffalo‐seasoned chicken breast.
$16.0
Loaded Cobb Salad$12.0
Baby Spinach And Bacon Salad$11.0
Kilkennys Country Chicken Salad
Steakouse SaladDessert
Rich traditional New York style cheesecake topped + a fresh strawberry sauce.
$10.0
Brownie Bottom PieA bennigan's classic. A chewy chocolate fudge brownie + vanilla ice cream on top; covered + hot fudge; whipped cream & a cherry.
$10.0
Legendary Death By ChocolateBennigan's original recipe of rich chocolate ice cream; almonds; mini‐marshmallows; chocolate fudge sauce & twix cookie bars; on a crumbled oreo cookie crust & covered in a chocolate shell. Pour on a side of hot chocolate topping. Bennigan's signature
$10.0
Housemade Bread Pudding With Praline SauceThis dessert will just melt in your mouth. Our housemade bread pudding drenched in hot praline sauce then topped + a scoop of vanilla ice cream & powdered sugar.
$10.0Classic American Burgers
Our classic bennigan’s burger. Choose from American; Swiss; cheddar; pepper jack / bleu cheese crumbles.
$15.0Ribs
12 OZ PRIME RIB WITH MASHED POTATOES AND BROCCOLI. INCLUDES SOUP OR SALAD COOKED MEDIUM RARE
$28.0Lunch Specials
Garden / Caesar salad & a bowl of hand‐crafted soup.
$13.0Sandwiches
An Irish favorite! Sliced corned beef; sauerkraut; Swiss cheese; 1000 Island dressing served on Rye bread.
$16.0
Bennigan's Club With Soup Or Salad$13.0
Kilkennys Country Chicken Wrap
Bennigans Club SandwichSeafood
Simply grilled / Cajun seasoned. Served + roasted garlic mashed potatoes & broccoli sauté.
$21.0Pasta
Cajun grilled chicken; fettuccine pasta; smoked vegetables; & a Cajun cream sauce. Served + toasted garlic bread.
$14.0
Cajun Chicken And Shrimp PastaCajun grilled chicken & shrimp; fettuccine pasta; smoked vegetables & a made‐from‐scratch Cajun cream sauce. Served + toasted garlic bread.
$20.0Dinner Specials
Two chicken breasts infused + our heavenly Hawaiian marinade & topped + perfectly grilled pineapple rings finished + more Hawaiian glaze. Served + herb rice pilaf & broccoli sauté.
$17.0Entrées
Our signature; hand‐breaded bites served traditional / tossed in Buffalo sauce; + your choice of ranch / blue cheese dressing.
$13.0
Hogan's Egg RollsTender wraps filled + chicken; sweet corn; black beans & fresh herbs. Served + housemade pineapple sweet pepper cream sauce.
$12.0Fresh-Made Salads
Garden greens; spicy glazed pecans; Granny Smith apples; craisins; & bleu cheese crumbles tossed in maple vinaigrette dressing. Drizzled + a balsamic glaze.
$11.0Crafted Burgers
Cheddar cheese; BBQ sauce; Applewood smoked bacon & mustard. Choose a bun: White Bun; Wheat Bun; Pretzel Bun. Choose a style: Beef Patty (Rare); Beef Patty (Medium Rare); Veggie Patty.
$12.0Main Dishes
Corned Beef And CabbageSavory corned beef served over a wedge of braised cabbage; slathered in delectable GUINNESS au jus + a special mustard for dipping. Served + sautéed dilled carrots & buttery red potatoes
$25.0Entrees - Beef
Char-Grilled Flat Iron SteakAsian‐marinated; tender flat iron steak grilled to perfection & served + garlic mash potatoes & broccoli saute.
$21.0Vegetables
Broccoli Sauté$7.0Starters
Cheesy Potato SkinsThick cut potato skins filled + Colby cheese; bacon & green onions. Served + sour cream.
$13.0
Reuben FrittersNew! Everything you love about a Reuben in one delicious bite! Handmade + diced corned beef; sauerkraut; cream cheese & Swiss cheese; dipped in buttermilk & breaded in Panko breadcrumbs. Dusted + parsley & served + a side of Thousand Island
$13.0Crowd Pleasers
Flip's Super Loaded Nachos1 serious nacho! crispy corn tortilla chips loaded + grilled flat iron steak; made‐from‐scratch beef & bean dip; fresh chili + queso; melted Colby cheese; pico de gallo; cilantro & jalapeno peppers. Topped + shredded lettuce & guacamole; the
$19.0
The County Clare SamplerNachos; hogan's egg rolls & dubliner quesadillas. Vegetarian.
$14.0
Dubliner QuesadillasGarlic‐marinated chicken + Colby & monterrey Jack cheeses; flavorful spices & crispy fried onions folded in a flour tortilla. Served + salsa; pico de gallo & guacamole. Drizzled + lime sour cream.
$13.0
8 Piece Bennigan's Premium Buffalo Wings$12.0
Irish Tower O' Rings$9.0
Mix And Match Choose 3$17.0
Original Recipe Broccoli Bites$13.0
Mangia Mozzarella$12.0
Cheeseburger Pub Bites$13.0
Sheela's Sriracha Shrimp$13.0Hamburgers
Spicy Chipotle BurgerCrispy fried onions; Pepper Jack cheese; & freshly made chipotle garlic mayo.
$16.0Legendary Favorites
Our Signature Chicken TendersHand‐breaded & served + our Homestyle French Fries; kicked‐up coleslaw & smoky honey Dijon dressing. Try it + grilled chicken!
$16.0
Danny Boy Chicken$17.0
Passion Fruit Glazed Pork Chop$20.0
Finn's Beer-Battered Fish And Chips$16.0
Irishman Whiskey Glazed Chicken$17.0Ultimate Gourmet Burgers
The Big Irish2 mouth‐watering 1/2‐lb. beef burgers piled high; double‐decker style + double the toppings! Choose from any of our prime burgers!
$21.0
Guinness Glazed Bacon BurgerSlathered + bourbon‐infused bacon jam over melted American cheese & topped + crispy fried haystack onions.
$17.0Steaks
Kensington ClubGrilled 8oz. Top Sirloin marinated in our secret Kensington glaze & served + roasted garlic mashed potatoes & maple roasted brussels sprouts.
$21.0Choose 2
Mix And Match Choose 2$14.0Burgers-Mcginnty's Style
The Big Irish Burger$16.0Burger
The B. O. M. B. Burger$14.0
Irishman Whiskey Glazed Burger$14.0
The B.o.m.b. (Bacon Onion Marmalade Bourbon)$17.0
St. Brigid Burger$17.0
The Irishman Whiskey Glazed Burger$17.0Celebrated Sandwiches
World Famous Monte Cristo Sandwich$12.0
The Original Irish Dip Sandwich$12.0
Turkey O'toole Sandwich$14.0
Cajun Chicken O'toole Sandwich$15.0
Lina's Crispy Chicken Sandwich$15.0
World Famous Monte Cristo With Soup Or Salad$13.0
The Original Irish Dip$16.0Crown Pleasers
Irish Tower O'rings$12.0Sides
Kicked-Up Coleslaw$7.0Add On Cheese
Slice Of Cheese Add On$1.0Meat
Roast Prime RibSoups&Amp;Comma; Side Salads And Combos
Ultimate Baked Potato SoupSide Dishes
$7.0
Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes$7.0
Herb Rice Pilaf$7.0
Homestyle French Fries$7.0
Maple Roasted Brussels Sprouts$7.0
Offers
Exclusive restaurant offer: Slice Of Cheese Add On — 70% off for $0.3!