Carrington - EGG HARBOR

#40 - Pizza - EGG HARBOR, Pubs, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Carrington

Carrington
3.6 / 5 (2721 reviews)

Description

Dining at this restaurant offers a blend of highs and lows. While the fish fry and pasta dishes receive praise for their flavor and quality, other menu items, particularly the burger and curries, often fall flat. Service quality varies, with some patrons highlighting exceptional bartenders while others report unenthusiastic waitstaff. The atmosphere is generally pleasant, making it a suitable spot for casual outings, though the inconsistency in food and service may lead diners to consider other options. Overall, the restaurant shows potential but struggles to maintain a consistently enjoyable experience for its guests.

Last update: 22.01.2026 from: Michael

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 2721 reviews
soothing-souls
04.11.2023

My extended family goes on vacation every year at the resort. We always dine at the restaurant and the food is amazing. The service is exceptional and the atmosphere is lovely. We highly recommend it for dinner. Price per person is $100+.

rich-mcgee-2
04.11.2023

Expensive. The server was extremely friendly. However, the bar service was lacking. The food was delicious, although the NY strip had a lot of fat. I suggest trying the walleye piccata. Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

michelle-gasparek
04.11.2023

We were eagerly anticipating our dining experience at the restaurant. The ambiance was pleasant. However, our server, "Ken", provided incredibly poor service. He neglected to ask if we needed water, another drink, dessert, etc. He also failed to bring the condiments we had requested multiple times. His service was truly terrible and did not meet our expectations. Despite having reservations for the following night, we decided to cancel them due to the disappointing service we received. We have no intention of returning to this restaurant.

michael-christenson-2
28.02.2025

Terrible experience for me. We didn’t have a reservation but the hostess said she could seat us anyways. No one came to take our drink/food order for half an hour or more. Once they did take our order, drinks took a long time to come out. They were good drinks at least. When my steak came out it was comically small (definitely not an 8oz fillet). Also the steak was overcooked. At this point I’m not saying anything. I’m just never coming back. 2/5 would not recommend. Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 4

gloria-brda-2
28.02.2025

Mother’s Day is a special time. We attended brunch at The Carrington for our first visit there. The food was so-so. Much of it was cold or like warm. We felt that there should have been breakfast selections other than quiche. No sausage, bacon, eggs, etc. We had to bring our own used plates to the bartender. Would have been nice to have had some soft musicpiano or something. Maybe we’ll try again. Food: 3 Atmosphere: 3

Menu

  • Starters

    Landmark Smorgasbord
    Landmark Smorgasbord
    $32.1
    Walleye Piccata
    Walleye Piccata
    $32.1
    French Onion Poutine
    French Onion Poutine
    $17.1
  • House Specialties

    Carrington Ribs
    Carrington Ribs
    $22.1
  • Dessert

    Cherry Lemon Leche Cake
    Cherry Lemon Leche Cake
    $10.0
    Niagara Sundae
    Niagara Sundae
    $12.0

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the restaurant at no extra cost.

You can watch major sports events on a screen / TV right in the restaurant.

The rooms in the restaurant are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological disabilities.

You can also pay for your meals with various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.