Ye Olde - Dunnellon

#23 - Pizza - Dunnellon, Italian, Vegetarian

Ye Olde

Ye Olde
4.0 / 5 (1229 reviews)

Description

The local dining scene is abuzz with mixed feedback about a recently renovated restaurant. While some patrons celebrate the robust flavors and generous portions of dishes like the pepperoni pizza and chef salads, others express frustration with service lapses and inconsistencies in food quality. Reports of cold meals and underwhelming flavors, particularly in subs and pizzas, have deterred certain guests. Despite the challenges, many appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff. With a fresh start under new ownership, the potential for improvement remains, inviting diners to explore the evolving menu. Time will tell if they can reclaim their former glory.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: RumAndPancakes

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 1229 reviews
rumandpancakes
18.10.2024

Great food but in desperate need of more ovens and more cooks. Only 2 cooks and 2 ovens. A large 1 topping pizza and half a sub took over an hour to make. Everything tasted great and the waitress was very apologetic about the wait. Would go again when it's less crowded or at least order takeout

joann-bentley
18.10.2024

I visited family in Florida, and they took me to this pizza place. The wait staff was friendly and took good care of all of us, although it seemed a bit understaffed during our visit. When our food arrived, it looked delicious and tasted even better. The kids ordered a 16-inch Meat Lovers Pizza, while I went with the Ye Old Sub. Overall, we had a great meal and it was quite affordable compared to where I live. On our way out, I spoke with the owner and his wife, who mentioned that they had just taken over the restaurant less than a year ago. I was really impressed and wish them all the best!

jessie-lovesdogs
18.10.2024

I would have given this place Neg starts if I could. My partner and I came there tonight and they were practically empty except for two other small parties. I ordered a 6 inch sub and my partner ordered a 12 inch sub. We sat and sat and sat. So about 40 min later our waiter comes out and hands my partner his meal only but a 6 inch. And the waiter said something along the line of “yeh we forgot you orders a 12 so we are making the other half” and we inquired about my food and was just told “ they are working on it.” So we sat for maybe another 20 min and my partners food is getting cold and still nothing….so we ended up leaving. Just super disappointed because I have loved that place and have been going there since I was young.

mosaicstonegirl
18.10.2024

Just visited this restaurant for the first time following new ownership. I had a small Chef Salad. Hubby had a Mini Calzone. They were DELICIOUS! Our friends had a Calzone and salad. They were very impressed with their meal as well. We highly recommend. Service was great. Food was delicious with quality ingredients and generous portions. Will be back soon. Found out they are closed Monday and Thursday.

robert-ricketts-insh
18.10.2024

Since the new owners took over this business has went down hill. The owner is rude and cocky and the food doesnt taste good like it used to i think they uses cheap products honestly. Horrible service also go to another place!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.