Reviews
What Ryan Caligiuri doesn't like about Colarusso's Coal Fired Pizza:
3.5/5. We've been wanting to try this place for a few months since moving here and finally got the opportunity over the weekend. Outstanding food at a reasonable price, but the service was horrible, probably best to take out instead of dining in. I'm pretty confident we interacted with every member of the wait staff there, but didn't seem to have a waiter/waitress assigned to us. My wife and I legitimately watched what we thought to be our waiter walk around and check on every table other than our own, which resulted in never getting refills until we waved someone down and a handful of other delays in service. What Rosann Schreiber likes about Colarusso's Coal Fired Pizza:
The wings with caramelized onions are fabulous, and so is the house salad. And my very favorite is the shrimp and hot pepper pizza. Yum! Wait staff is attentive and personable. The only thing I don't like is the acoustics in the area by the bar. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: House Salad View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I'm giving this restaurant 5 stars. Even though I preferred their previous location, the food quality has remained consistent. We especially enjoy the house sal...
read moreThe restaurant offers fantastic food and exceptional service. It can get crowded, so it is advisable to call ahead and confirm availability and menu options bef...
read moreThis restaurant is excellent with delicious food and friendly staff. They provide generous portions without charging exorbitant prices.
3.5/5. We've been wanting to try this place for a few months since moving here and finally got the opportunity over the weekend. Outstanding food at a reasonabl...
read morePhenomenal service great atmosphere the pizza the wings and especially like their cheese steak.Been to many gatherings in their Party /ballroom area.
Colarusso's has garnered a mix of accolades and critiques in recent reviews, highlighting its flavorful offerings and service challenges. Diners rave about the unique pizza combinations, such as shrimp and hot pepper, and house-made meatballs, with many praising the attentive waitstaff and inviting atmosphere. However, some experiences reveal significant service delays, particularly during busy nights, leading to frustration over forgotten orders and lapses in drink service. While the food is generally well-received, particularly for its pizza and wings, the inconsistent service has left some patrons questioning their return. Reservations are recommended to enhance the dining experience.
I love going to this restaurant for their signature salad and white pizza!
The pizza at this restaurant was excellent. The service was very friendly and accommodating, offering a variety of thin crust options to choose from.
2nd time there I love wood fire pizza good prices and salads are great too as well
Didn't try their pizza but ordered my burger med rare and it was very well done so couldn't eat it. They do have a really good white cosmo I highly recommend an...
read moreNoisy so hard to have a conversation. Waitress was never around. Food was average at best. Glorified pizza place with no atmosphere.