Reviews
What LoriH likes about Carmine's Mcgregor Square:
Totally surprised to find this restaurant is NOT affiliated with Carmines in NYC! We asked when we were seated...and heard just about every other table ask the same question as they were seated. To be honest that was the draw when we made our reservations. The menu is similar, family style dinner-same as NYC. Food was good, service GREAT... but dang! Feeling deceived here! View all feedback.
What Obreten Videkanić doesn't like about Carmine's Mcgregor Square:
The experience was decent. The atmosphere really varies based on where you're seated. The drinks were enjoyable. While I wouldn't choose this place for a special celebration, I would return for a casual dinner. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
While the food was quite enjoyable, the service left much to be desired. We waited 20 minutes before anyone came to our table, and it took an hour for our food...
read moreThe experience was decent. The atmosphere really varies based on where you're seated. The drinks were enjoyable. While I wouldn't choose this place for a specia...
read moreAmazing! It's family-style Italian cuisine with incredibly generous portions! Make sure to try their desserts, especially the lemon shrimp linguini and the limo...
read moreGreat service, excellent food, def need your server to describe the entrees menu needs to define the choices. Also they only do family style would prefer to ord...
read moreDinner rolls are delicious! Great wine and the house specials were great! Good place for families and couples!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe atmosphere is fantastic, and the staff is attentive and friendly. The food is consistently amazing, regardless of when we visit.
I'm really disappointed. Carmine's on Penn used to be my favorite spot for delicious Italian food, but this location was a letdown. The pasta was undercooked an...
read moreI had high hopes for Carmines! We visited on Saturday, February 10, to celebrate our anniversary, but it turned out to be quite disappointing. The salad was wil...
read moreGreat food and service...something you can always count on at Carmine's! They were busy with many large parties so a little loud for a more intimate dinner but...
read moreFirst time at this location. Just not the same “neighborhood atmosphere” as on Penn. I guess the restaurant chic decor doesn't really match family style Italian...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more