Casey's - Decatur

Pizza, Salads, Breakfast
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +12174228969

Menu

The menu of Casey's from Decatur comprises about 88 different courses and drinks. On average you pay about $9.9 for a dish / drink.

At Casey's, experiences vary widely from enthusiastic praise to significant disappointment. While some customers commend the delicious Flatbread Chicken Bacon Ranch and enjoy the friendly, attentive service from staff members, others highlight ongoing issues with rudeness and inefficiency that tarnish the dining experience. Complaints about incorrect orders, inadequate staffing, and unprofessional behavior have emerged, prompting some patrons to vow never to return. Despite these discrepancies, many appreciate the cleanliness of the establishment and the occasional standout employee, indicating a potential for improvement if management addresses persistent service issues.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Shelly

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Outside

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 1761 reviews

Was Gabe B at Casey's a mag?
Despite a very late delivery from my DoorDash drivers, who accepted my order for four pizzas while en route to my house and made me wait an extra 45 minutes, the pizzas weren't extremely cold and tasted similar to Casey's. The slices were quite uneven, but overall, they were enjoyable. View all feedback.

What Jeremy K dislikes about Casey's:
The pizza arrived with just four slices of jalapeño, only a small amount of brisket that I’d estimate was worth about $0.13, and hardly any BBQ sauce. The onions were decent, though. View all feedback.

gabe-b-elephant054
Gabe 13.01.2024 - 22:40

Despite a very late delivery from my DoorDash drivers, who accepted my order for four pizzas while en route to my house and made me wait an extra 45 minutes, the pizzas weren't extremely cold and tasted similar to Casey's. The slices were quite uneven, but overall, they were enjoyable.

jeremy-k-bush87
Jeremy 13.01.2024 - 22:40

The pizza arrived with just four slices of jalapeño, only a small amount of brisket that I’d estimate was worth about $0.13, and hardly any BBQ sauce. The onions were decent, though.

rick-j-ivy7
Rick 13.01.2024 - 22:40

I didn’t receive my 12-pack of Mountain Dew; I only got a 12-pack of Sprite instead. What happened? I paid for two 12-packs.

shelly
Shelly 22.06.2024 - 04:43

Their pizza is amazing! So delicious

nicholas-ernst
Nicholas 22.06.2024 - 04:43

I picked up some pizza tonight (09/02/23) and I just have to say, if you don’t enjoy your job, maybe it’s time to reconsider being there. I’m generally a happy person, and it takes a lot to get me down, but I think they need to improve their staff. Additionally, it shouldn’t be that hard to follow the order on the screen; making pizza isn’t rocket science! This experience is one of the reasons I’ve stopped ordering out. Unfortunately, many places and their staff just don’t meet expectations.

  • Beer & Hard Seltzer

    Bud Light Seltzer Variety 12Pk
    Bud Light Seltzer Variety 12Pk
    $22.1
    Busch Light 12 Pack
    Busch Light 12 Pack
    $17.6
    Miller Lite 12 Pack
    Miller Lite 12 Pack
    $17.3
    Corona Extra Lager 12 Pack
    Corona Extra Lager 12 Pack
    $22.1
    Coors Light 12 Pack
    Coors Light 12 Pack
    $17.3
  • Alcohol - 12 Packs Of Beer

    White Claw Variety 12 Pack
    White Claw Variety 12 Pack
    $22.3

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.