Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Tristan Schroer likes about Johnny Fontane's:
A great find and a classy joint. My only quibble was the slow food service the night my friends and I were there. However, I can overlook this because the head chef was sick and it is a new restaurant so there is understandably going to be some teething problems. Great for cocktails, get-togethers and dare I say it, dates. View all feedback.
What Disappointed doesn't like about Johnny Fontane's:
Was so incredibly disappointed with our meal on Friday night. We were seated in an area downstairs with 2 group tables which was very noisy for the 2 of us, we were unsure whether to order at the bar or wait for wait staff and upon waiting at the bar to be served was told the order could be taken at the table, and the Capone pizza was so amazingly tasteless and unpleasing. Everything about that pizza tasted like noth... View all feedback.
Loved it loved it loved it! I've tried Deep Dish Pizza in Chicago, and in my opinion Johnny Fontane's was even better than the original. We came on a Thursday when it wasn't too busy, and the staff really went the extra mile to cater to our every need. If you're coming on a weeknight, I'd recommend arriving between 5 and 7pm for Happy Hour. 10 cocktails? yeah!
Was so incredibly disappointed with our meal on Friday night. We were seated in an area downstairs with 2 group tables which was very noisy for the 2 of us, we were unsure whether to order at the bar or wait for wait staff and upon waiting at the bar to be served was told the order could be taken at the table, and the Capone pizza was so amazingly tasteless and unpleasing. Everything about that pizza tasted like nothing. No garlic? No salt and pepper even? Couldn't finish a second slice. Took the rest home to feed our dog. Won't be back.
Great potential but didn't cope well with the busy Saturday night. Would recommend going on a weeknight.
My Boyfriend and I went for dinner and we have both tried deep dish pizza in Chicago so we were really excited to have it in Sydney. The pizza left a lot to be desired, it felt like a thick crust with a lot of sauce rather than a deep dish so wasn't really the experience we were looking for. Flavors were OK but it just could have been so much better. Had to go to the bar to order food and drink which is far from ideal since we were seated upstairs and the bar was downstairs. I think with this kind of cuisine, table service is needed for recommendations etc. It just annoyed us so it was a bit of a turn off. They also charged us full price for the drinks during happy hour. Overall a disappointing experience, I do think the bar has a lot of potential if they are willing to tweak a few things. Won't be going back though :
Food here was ahhh mazing! Best arancini balls I've had to date full of flavour! I'm from interstate but the Capone deep dish pizza is now on my list of favourite meals ever! The oreo ricotta cannoli was delicious and great value for money.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
