Reviews - Captain's Table

We ate at the Captains Table on a Monday night in September. I wasn’t impressed by how the place looked on the outside but given our choices in Custer were very... read more We ate at the Captains Table on a Monday night in September. I wasn’t impressed by how the place looked on the outside but given our choices in Custer were very limited on a Monday, I decided to take a chance. It was a VERY BAD decision. Firstimpressions count and it was awful. The place smelled of stale smoke, the serve had dirty clothes, didn’t look like he hadshowered in some time, and had missing teeth. The inside looked old (as in REALLY old) and run down. The waitress was not veryquick but seemed friendly. First, she messed up the beer ordered but given I asked for Kona, and she thought I said Corona, Igive her some grace. The food was very greasy, and my shrimp was missing the cocktail sauce, the only other item it was to beserved with. By the time we were done eating, all we wanted to do was get out of there as quickly as we could. I gave thewaitress my credit card and she returned with the bill. The bill was in a black case and truthfully, since my card was a verydeep blue, I don’t know if the card was with the bill and I was so anxious to leave that I missed it or it was not returned. Ididn’t discover the missing card until the next day. The restaurant isn’t open on Tuesday or Wednesday and there is noafter-hours number posted. When I contacted the credit card company, I learned four additional charges had been made about anhour after we left. I contacted the police who discovered the card was on the counter next to the credit card machine. The storyI was told is that the machine was extremely sensitive and picked up my card when the four other charges were made. This seems abit fishy and furthermore, it seems odd that no one questioned the fact the card was sitting there and made no attempt tocontact the credit card company who could have notified me. I urge any traveler to Custer South Dakota to avoid this place evenif it is a Monday night. You are better off at fast food restaurant than at this place. I give it no stars but unless I give a

Carla is a gem of a waitress and was helpful and hospitable the whole time! The infused cinnamon apple and orange liquors were delicious. The fish and chips was... read more Carla is a gem of a waitress and was helpful and hospitable the whole time! The infused cinnamon apple and orange liquors were delicious. The fish and chips was great and so was the hash brown casserole side. Yummy house made ranch as well. Greatexperience overall, but I think the entrees were a bit overpriced given the portion size. The service and food itself wasotherwise a thumbs up.

Go Here only if you can't drive to any other restaurant!!!!!! And then if you go only order the overprised $10 fries but bring your own salt shaker. You will sa... read more Go Here only if you can't drive to any other restaurant!!!!!! And then if you go only order the overprised $10 fries but bring your own salt shaker. You will save money on the tip because severs is a -5 and they watch your every move. I was staving beforeI left the building. And spent well over hundred bucks our 1st time ever wanting to return our food and run as fast as possibleelsewhere. From service to food I give it a negative 1000000000000 . Run and run anywhere else

It wasn't bad. Server was really nice. The food, that we ordered, was frozen to deep fried. I think it was a bit pricey as nothing was actually prepared there.... read more It wasn't bad. Server was really nice. The food, that we ordered, was frozen to deep fried. I think it was a bit pricey as nothing was actually prepared there. Frozen shrimp, fish and fries....deep fried and served on fancy plates.

Carla is a gem of a waitress and was helpful and hospitable the whole time! The infused cinnamon apple and orange liquors were delicious. The fish and chips was... read more Carla is a gem of a waitress and was helpful and hospitable the whole time! The infused cinnamon apple and orange liquors were delicious. The fish and chips was great and so was the hash brown casserole side. Yummy house made ranch as well. Great experience overall, but I think the entrees were a bit overpriced given the portion size. The service and food itself was otherwise a thumbs up.