Barb's Pizza - Cromwell

I can't help but laugh at all the negative reviews. I stopped by for a quick slice of cheese after finishing up my taxes, and it was honestly the best slice I've had in Connecticut without making the trek to New Haven or New York City. In my opinion, the NYC/New Haven style isn't meant to be piled high with toppings unless you're planning to eat it right away. Just one or maybe two toppings max; otherwise, it’ll turn soggy. The crust is beautifully thin, crispy, and delicate, while the edge is both airy and chewy. My only gripe is the price for a slice, which is $4. But I’ll definitely return for a whole pie—much better value!

I really enjoy the pizza here, but my last couple of visits haven't been great. I think the owner should consider hiring a new pizza chef alongside the one who always looks half asleep. He tends to give off a negative vibe. Additionally, I still haven't received my refund because it was processed through a discount offer, which has been quite a hassle.

I ordered two small pizzas online, but one of them was incorrect. I called the restaurant, and they made a new pizza for my boyfriend, but unfortunately, that one was also wrong. The staff was friendly, but I won’t be ordering from there again, as the taste was very disappointing.

Been twice for pizza and once for sandwiches. Owner is nice. Toppings are flavorful however this is not New Haven style Ahbeets. Crust is a bit thick, doughy and definitely underdone. Even asked for crispy. Sandwich order was wrong.

I am from New York and this pizza is top notch! Service is immaculate and the pizza is amazing! The place is so lovely too! Recommend 1000/1000