Prima Pizza - Cornwall

Italian, Delivery Services, Pizza

Prima Pizza, nestled in the charming town of Cornwall, NY, is a beloved Italian eatery that boasts an impressive 4.3-star rating. With hours from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM, it's the perfect spot for both intimate dinners and larger celebrations—just call ahead at (845) 534-7003 to reserve your table. Enjoy the convenience of ordering your favorite dishes from home via Uber Eats or DoorDash. With a diverse menu that includes vegetarian options and a selection of beers to accompany your meal, there's something for everyone at Prima Pizza. If you're exploring similar dining experiences, be sure to check out Shamrock Tavern and ASPIRE One Communications. Have you visited Prima Pizza? We would love to hear your review!.

Last update: 14.12.2025 from: Robert

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 1144 reviews

Prima Pizza delivers old‑school Italian comfort with crisp thin‑crust pies, generous portions and homemade specialties—meatballs, stromboli, calzones and nostalgic desserts. This family‑run, cozy spot near West Point/Cornwall pairs friendly, attentive service with carryout and delivery options. Gluten‑free cauliflower crust and hearty pasta dinners are available, and a beer‑forward bar complements a modest wine selection. Regulars praise the welcoming, retro atmosphere; expect great value and big portions in a compact, lively space.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Good pizza! We have a pizza with many toppings (pepperoni, sausage, vegetables and the 16 were a great amount of food. This pizza could easily take 4 or 5 meals. The store has a beautiful old school vibe that probably hasn't changed since it opened in the 1950s(? .

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Great advertising ?Try the slice of life.? When I asked what that was, I was informed every slice is the slice of life. They weren?t wrong! Delicious pie, great place. Cozy atmosphere. Would definitely frequent there if I lived closer.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

We visited on our drive back from Beacon, NY to NJ. Stumbled across this place and loved it! Beautiful little garden and great food!

Robert 26.03.2025 - 12:45

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

What a delightful experience. The pizza was delicious with a thin crust, lots of sauce and fresh, juicy tomatoes. You have to try the huge meatballs, very tender and tasty. The owner, Anthony came over to chat with us. Our server, Thomas was so polite,friendly and also chatted with us and made us feel right at home. The restaurant has a ?back in time? look and feel. Even thebackground music is ?a blast from the past?. All the young men working in the restaurant go non-stop and do it with such awelcoming smile. Many thanks to the entire team for making our dinner such an unforgettable experience.

Kicktrimp 26.03.2025 - 12:45

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Pizza is straight out of the Bronx, Brooklyn all over the place , my point is the pizza is one of the best tasting pizza I?ve ever had

Feedback