Olive Pit - Corning

Cafe, Burgers, Coffee
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Olive Pit

Olive Pit
4.5 / 5 (451 reviews)

Description

**A Mixed Bag at The Olive Pit**

The Olive Pit provides a unique pit stop for travelers, boasting an extensive selection of olives and gourmet products. While the friendly staff and delightful offerings, such as the flavorful milkshakes and rich olive oils, receive praise, some dishes fall short of expectations. Diners have reported overpriced sandwiches lacking sides, and inconsistent food quality can detract from the experience. Despite these setbacks, many continue to return for the fun flavors and enjoyable atmosphere. While the charm of the past isn’t always present, the Olive Pit remains a popular destination for travelers along I-5.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Aaron

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 451 reviews
aaron
03.07.2024

Great food, they have a great selection of jar olives, jams and such. And they have a few kitchen things that are good quality.

leandra-paasch
03.07.2024

The burger and milkshake were both delicious!

lisa-crowell-1
03.07.2024

This is the first time I have eaten here, I ordered the muffeletta sandwich and Chai milkshake and my dad got a hot dog and latte total $40! PRICEY WITH NO SIDES, MUFFELETTA WAS OK OLIVES TOOK OVER THE WHOLE FLAVOR OF SANDWICH, CHAI MILKSHAKE WAS YUMMY THOUGH

wendy-lindsay-pilot5
03.07.2024

By the time we travel to California, my family and I have to stop at the Olive Pit. They have amazing milkshakes, wonderful products, including California oils, and decent wine selection. Typically their staff is wonderful but this recent trip was ruined by edgy and cranky younger cashiers.

callie-main-1
03.07.2024

Very disappointing. I was here just a couple years ago and remember a true restaurant atmosphere. This time I could have been at Burger King or Carl’s Jr. No salad on the menu, no fries or sides. The burgers were good, the bread on the BLT was good, but I won’t be back. Sorry.

FAQ

The second closest station is Amtrak Thruway-Corning, located 769 meters away.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.