Premier Diner - Commack

There's nothing quite like a classic diner! The atmosphere was just what you would expect, complete with traditional booths. When we were seated, we were presen... read more There's nothing quite like a classic diner! The atmosphere was just what you would expect, complete with traditional booths. When we were seated, we were presented with a plate of beets as an appetizer... an unusual choice, but I didn’t mind it. They offer all the usual fare. I would suggest sticking with burgers, sandwiches, or breakfast items, as those tend to be consistently good. I ordered the corned beef sandwich, and I was very pleased with it! The side of coleslaw and pickles was also just right. I would definitely be happy to return and dine here again!

The Premier Diner is the premier diner! See what I did there? We absolutely love coming here for dinner it's been around forever, and so have many of the staff,... read more The Premier Diner is the premier diner! See what I did there? We absolutely love coming here for dinner it's been around forever, and so have many of the staff, and you can really feel it. They treat everyone like regulars and I always feel like I'm sitting down for a big family meal together with all of the other customers. I love that they serve a chick pea salad as a starter instead of bread this gluten free babe loves legumes! Best things on the menu: Burgers, chicken fingers, beef barley soup, dessert. Some of the big chicken entrees are great too. Don't order: the salads. They need to improve their salad game. The Mexican salad was OK, but the chef salad was an insult to chef salads everywhere. Like a big slab of rolled up meat on top of a sad bed of iceberg. I could barely eat it. No one really goes to diners for salads, so I'll take the L on ordering it at all but sometimes you just want a salad to go along with the delicious masterpiece that is the beef barley soup, y'know? I'll keep going to this place forever even if they don't fix their salad issues. It's the feeling of the place, the service, the honest to goodness diner vibes. I just love it. Don't miss out.

I appreciate how quickly you're seated and the excellent service from the staff. The food is standard diner fare, but the prices are much higher than what you'd... read more I appreciate how quickly you're seated and the excellent service from the staff. The food is standard diner fare, but the prices are much higher than what you'd typically find at a diner. I wish I could say the cost is justified, but there's really nothing exceptional about the experience that makes me feel good about paying nearly 50% more than other local diners.

If you know what to get this will be the best diner on Long Island for you and your family. Vibes are high. Food is incredible. service is quick. Everything you... read more If you know what to get this will be the best diner on Long Island for you and your family. Vibes are high. Food is incredible. service is quick. Everything you want in a diner.

This restaurant was excellent! We were seated quickly despite the crowd, thanks to the ample seating available. In the photo, you can see my Western omelette, w... read more This restaurant was excellent! We were seated quickly despite the crowd, thanks to the ample seating available. In the photo, you can see my Western omelette, which came with whole wheat toast and home fries—it was delicious and quite filling, so I ended up bringing some food home. We also enjoyed the challah French toast, along with egg, sausage, and home fries. I will definitely be returning!