Emilio's - Commack

I have never experienced such rudeness from restaurant staff before! To summarize my visit, both the owner's daughter and a waitress I had never encountered wer... read more I have never experienced such rudeness from restaurant staff before! To summarize my visit, both the owner's daughter and a waitress I had never encountered were extremely disrespectful for no apparent reason. After a brief disagreement about the waitress's behavior, the owner's daughter delivered our food with a laugh and made sarcastic remarks, which prompted me to decide against eating it. When she asked what the issue was, I informed her that I was leaving, and her response was to insult me, calling me a "miserable b**ch" and suggesting that I must hate my life! (Keep in mind, I had never even met her before!) The atmosphere was incredibly unwelcoming, and with so many excellent Italian restaurants in the area, I would strongly advise steering clear of this one.

The new bartender really knows how to mix drinks. The food is fantastic, and the service is excellent! I would rate it a perfect 10 out of 10! read more The new bartender really knows how to mix drinks. The food is fantastic, and the service is excellent! I would rate it a perfect 10 out of 10!

The food was excellent. I had a shrimp parm hero that was excellent. The service was a bit slow. read more The food was excellent. I had a shrimp parm hero that was excellent. The service was a bit slow.

If you choose a dish that you enjoy, you can expect consistent quality each time. However, the overall atmosphere feels a bit run-down, with torn chairs and boo... read more If you choose a dish that you enjoy, you can expect consistent quality each time. However, the overall atmosphere feels a bit run-down, with torn chairs and booths. Additionally, the staff often seems to be in conflict, frequently arguing and raising their voices.

Because the person at the register was handling money, repeatedly adjusting his hat and picking at this ear I asked for a slice not to be heated. I didn't want... read more Because the person at the register was handling money, repeatedly adjusting his hat and picking at this ear I asked for a slice not to be heated. I didn't want those hands touching the pizza. I thought he said $40 and he got insulted when I asked $40 for a slice? I couldn't understand what he was saying until he told me I was rude! I replied why because I don't understand Mexican or Spanish? He became hostile when I told him he owed me a dollar. If he clips a $1 from every customer for his shift he's doing well. No, it wasn't an error, it happened at another restaurant too. Count your change if you get singles back.