Catfish Annie's - Commack
Catfish Annie's
Menu
A complete menu of Catfish Annie's from Commack featuring all 8 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.
Catfish Annie’s is a beloved, family-run seafood restaurant known for its fresh, high-quality dishes and generous portions at reasonable prices. With nearly 50 years of history, it offers standout specials like crab cakes, seafood bisque, and lobster dishes that consistently delight patrons. The welcoming, attentive staff enhances the experience, creating a warm, family-friendly atmosphere, though some find the décor dated and local crowds occasionally loud. Cleanliness and service are top-notch, contributing to a reliable dining experience. While prices on bulk seafood may be higher than competitors, the overall quality and care make Catfish Annie’s a Long Island favorite worth visiting.
Images
Feedback
Was Kenn Hintz at Catfish Annie's a mag?
The food was excellent—fresh and abundant with generous portions. While the atmosphere was just average, the restaurant’s cleanliness stood out. The service was impressive as well. My wife and I will certainly be back! View all feedback.
What Uncle Tone dislikes about Catfish Annie's:
This is a fantastic family-friendly seafood restaurant, featuring a very friendly and capable staff. The prices and portion sizes are more than sufficient, but the ambiance feels stuck in the 1980s. Unfortunately, some local customers tend to be loud and demanding, which detracts from the potential of this well-managed establishment. Change is important, Anthony! Your staff deserves better than rude patrons and entit... View all feedback.
The food was excellent—fresh and abundant with generous portions. While the atmosphere was just average, the restaurant’s cleanliness stood out. The service was impressive as well. My wife and I will certainly be back!
I recently contacted this restaurant to inquire about prices for a large catering event, specifically needing 30 lobsters weighing 1 1/4 pounds each. When I learned that the price was over $20 per pound, I mentioned that Uncle Giuseppe’s and Stop & Shop were both charging $15 per pound. I was surprised to find their prices 25% higher. I expected a seafood market to offer better rates. The girl’s response was simply, "Then go shop there." I will never buy from them again.
Catfish Annie's provides outstanding quality in every dish, all within a clean and inviting atmosphere at great prices. The staff is friendly and welcoming, which enhances the overall experience. The seafood is incredibly delicious and surpasses anything you would find at other restaurants. This place is truly exceptional, and I can't wait to return!
This is a fantastic family-friendly seafood restaurant, featuring a very friendly and capable staff. The prices and portion sizes are more than sufficient, but the ambiance feels stuck in the 1980s. Unfortunately, some local customers tend to be loud and demanding, which detracts from the potential of this well-managed establishment. Change is important, Anthony! Your staff deserves better than rude patrons and entitled locals. It’s time to elevate and evolve. Great job, team!
Quick-serve restaurant and retail fish counter Parking: Busy lot
Full Menu
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.4 / 5 (1124 reviews)Italian Wine Pasta Cheese SaladAndrea's 25
Jericho Turnpike 6300, 11725 Commack, US
"Excellent food,amazing service! Truly a hidden GEM!"
★ 4.3 / 5 (5951 reviews)#3 Seafood in Commack Spanish TapasSangria 71
Jericho Turnpike 1095, 11725 Commack, US
"Service was wonderful as always. Loved our waitress."
★ 4.3 / 5 (8734 reviews)#14 Vegetarian in Commack Pizza SushiMannino's Italian Kitchen And Lounge
Jericho Turnpike 2158, 11725 Commack, US
"It was always a great experience. The food was fantastic! "