Rockmill Tavern - Columbus

Finally made it in here for dinner the other night, and I'm glad we did! I love the feel of the spaceIt's very rustic & a little modern. read more Finally made it in here for dinner the other night, and I'm glad we did! I love the feel of the spaceIt's very rustic & a little modern.

Sat at the bar and Robert was taking care of us. He made amazing drinks for us. You MUST try one of his specials. The food was served quickly and was cooked per... read more Sat at the bar and Robert was taking care of us. He made amazing drinks for us. You MUST try one of his specials. The food was served quickly and was cooked perfectly. I will be back!

The service and ambiance here was excellent. The menu was very well rounded. We got filet mignon and Royal Red Shrimp to share with salads, sauteed garlic mushr... read more The service and ambiance here was excellent. The menu was very well rounded. We got filet mignon and Royal Red Shrimp to share with salads, sauteed garlic mushrooms and baked potato. There were baskets of a variety of breads and two kinds of butter. Truffles were provided at the end of the meal. It was a beautiful dining experience!

I was very disappointed with the service we received at this restaurant. Our server, Bentley, did not bother to check if our food was prepared to our liking. De... read more I was very disappointed with the service we received at this restaurant. Our server, Bentley, did not bother to check if our food was prepared to our liking. Despite my request for my dish to be cooked all the way through, Bentley did not ensure this was done. When he was clearing my plate, I noticed that the last 2 inches of the fish were raw and inedible. Bentley immediately defended himself, saying he had asked the chef to cook it through. If he had checked on my meal sooner, I would have asked for the fish to be recooked. Unfortunately, by the time I brought this to his attention, everyone in my party had already finished their meals.

The restaurant was very accommodating to our group of seven, despite the limited menu options. The food was outstanding, although the noise level was high becau... read more The restaurant was very accommodating to our group of seven, despite the limited menu options. The food was outstanding, although the noise level was high because of the large crowd.