Marnanteli's Pizza - Cold Spring

#8 - Pizza - Cold Spring, Chicken, Bbq

Marnanteli's Pizza

Marnanteli's Pizza
4.3 / 5 (1693 reviews)

Description

Marnanteli's restaurant receives rave reviews for its delicious food and great service. Customers praise the portion sizes and variety of menu options, especially the pizza. The overall atmosphere and cleanliness of the restaurant also earn high marks. While some reviewers mention issues with online ordering or payment holds, the majority of feedback is overwhelmingly positive. With friendly staff, tasty food, and a welcoming environment, Marnanteli's is a top choice for a dining experience in the area.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Laurel

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 1693 reviews
laurel01
23.05.2025

The food is good, and the portion sizes are okay for the price. The online ordering is absolutely terrible. Clunky user experience, no email/print option for the receipt, no explanation of the point system. And probably the biggest, cheapest,STUPIDEST part is it puts a hold on your card. A hold. It doesn't just do the math and charge you what's needed, no. It holdsfar more than necessary for DAYS. While writing this, I checked my bank account for past purchases and found them NOT CORRECTwhen compared to the saved screenshot of the order confirmation. Time to get with the 19th century and build a proper orderportal.

bertrand89-1
23.05.2025

Excellent cleanliness, customer service and adherence to high quality on a consistent basis; rating based on 4 subsequent, random visits over two years. Quality speaks for itself, no food-photos required. ???? Management and ownership clearly getit , of note, the seasonal and regular off-menu specials are impressive i.e., Fredin pizza was delicious and affordable. Worththe visit off highway 23 in Cold Spring for those wanting fresh, creative, family friendly options.

mike-vinar
15.10.2023

We haven't tried the broasted chicken yet but the pizza is excellent. The sauce is amazing! Without a good sauce, it doesn't matter what else is on it. Excellent service and pizza!!

brandon
20.01.2024

You charged a tip to my credit card even though my mom's friend left one on the table. That's ridiculous!

tylor-pralle
15.10.2023

The food is good, and the portion sizes are okay for the price. The online ordering is absolutely terrible. Clunky user experience, no email/print option for the receipt, no explanation of the point system. And probably the biggest, cheapest, STUPIDEST part is it puts a hold on your card. A hold. It doesn't just do the math and charge you what's needed, no. It holds far more than necessary for DAYS. While writing this, I checked my bank account for past purchases and found them NOT CORRECT when compared to the saved screenshot of the order confirmation. Time to get with the 19th century and build a proper order portal.

FAQ

You can use the WiFi of the place at no extra cost.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.