Brooklyn Bakery - City of Olean

Best pizza I've ever tasted. It's about the crust. Somehow they have made it possible to have a thin, wood-fired crust with the perfect combination of crispy and chewiness. The crust has a rustic flavor that more matches an artesian bread than pizza dough. Unlike any other pizza, I wanted more crust. The amount of sauce and toppings were perfect to allow the crust to support themselves, which is not a small feat for a wood-fired cake. I had to travel with a cake for 2 hours so that the owner parked the pizzas and I had finished them at home so that it would not taste like residues. I preheated a pizza stone for 45 minutes at 500 before I finish the cakes for 6 minutes. All I can say it was amazing! They are just a small hole in the wall, but it's really worth finding.

The best pizza I had (thin crust/ NY style). This guy is passionate and works hard to make his dough right, and you can say it. It's a bit cheesy, crispy, just really good. Baking bricks (with hardwood no less) adds it only. It is somewhat more expensive than some other places, but you get a really high-quality pizza from it. The location can be confusing, but once you find it (included behind the video shop) it is completely worth it. I love supporting a local craftsman and getting a great pizza from the store!

Pizza was thin crust (we prefer thicker), but was crisp and chewing, and good taste. The owner who apparently lives next door came by and was friendly and speechful when he made the pizza before us. Location is somewhat strange as it is behind the family video AND a house on the adjacent street. It's unclear where you can park, so we just park in the family video and walk. There is no dining room to talk about it, but maybe that will change when it grows. Overall, delicious food, friendly, fast service.

The best pizza in Olean hands down. We're regular guests. Eating has never been disappointed that we have been ordering faithfully for 5 years.

This pizza was great! The crust is a thinner style and comes out with an authentic wood fired flavor. I always order my pizzas with extra sauce and I was very glad I did this time because it seemed to then be on par with a standard level of sauce on typical chain pizzas. The pepperoni reminded me very much of Linguiça and was phenomenal. I'll admit: it was a little odd to walk into someone's backyard to pick up my takeout. Once you're there however, you'll find the separate garage to be a professional pizza kitchen and full takeout establishment! This local gem is located behind Family Video and is accessible from either their parking lot or directly from the front on 14th Street. Call in advance or walk in to order, either way I doubt you'll regret it!