Carlo Johnny - Cincinnati

My wife and I celebrated our 4th anniversary at Carlo Johnny, and it was the best culinary experience we've ever had. Our server, Joe, was humble, attentive, an... read more My wife and I celebrated our 4th anniversary at Carlo Johnny, and it was the best culinary experience we've ever had. Our server, Joe, was humble, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable about both the menu and the history of the building. Highly recommended!

My daughters held a rehearsal in the Liquor Room. The space is beautifully decorated, featuring doors that allow for a cozy and intimate dinner experience. read more My daughters held a rehearsal in the Liquor Room. The space is beautifully decorated, featuring doors that allow for a cozy and intimate dinner experience.

As much as I love steak, it’s surprising that I had never been to a Jeff Ruby's restaurant before. Last Christmas, they had a gift card sale, and... read more As much as I love steak, it’s surprising that I had never been to a Jeff Ruby's restaurant before. Last Christmas, they had a gift card sale, and...

We had a fantastic time celebrating a college graduation! A big thanks to Ashlee for assisting us with our large party reservations, and to Adrian for his excep... read more We had a fantastic time celebrating a college graduation! A big thanks to Ashlee for assisting us with our large party reservations, and to Adrian for his exceptional service. The food was delicious, and the location was stunning. It truly was a perfect day. We appreciate the entire staff for making our celebration even more special.

We came here for our anniversary. The ambiance was pleasant, but we had a 20 25 minute wait, despite having reservations (there seemed to be a lot going on at t... read more We came here for our anniversary. The ambiance was pleasant, but we had a 20 25 minute wait, despite having reservations (there seemed to be a lot going on at the hostess desk). The crab cake is delicious and would happily recommend to anyone! However the steaks weren't seasoned well and the mashed potatoes had a lot of garlic salt added. Truth be told, we've had better food at lesser steak houses for half the price. Their butter pie cheesecake dessert was phenomenal as well! They did do a complimentary photo (which was very sweet) and brought out some Prosecco and dessert for our anniversary celebration we thought this was a wonderful touch. While everyone was very kind and accommodating, I don't know that we'd go back. The service was wonderful, but the food (for the most part) seems to be living on popularity hype.